A Song of Ice and Fire [EPILOGUE]

Status
Not open for further replies.
[KILL]: Lycanthropy (Joffrey)

I don't get what this cowardice is against killing the King. Sure, Jaime gets a kill. ONE kill. And not permanently, I don't think. Just man up you wimps and kill the most evil, disgusting, vicious character Game of Thrones saw, until Ramsay was introduced haha. Let's spark an event already! (Because I'm pretty sure that yes, killing Joffrey will spark an event)

And besides. You only need to look him up to know that Joffrey NEEDS to die. Kill him now.
 
I don't see a point in killing Beiber if he's blocked. ;/ So, random kill:
Kill Cosmic
 
Exactly. He's blocked and can't do anything. I don't see why you're going to vote for him, unless you are Jaime of course. And for the people who are afraid of random voting, I can understand that and i don't like it either but I think it's better than wasting a big advantage that Dany gave us.

[kill] Sonata

I'll probably change this later.
 
The thing is we don't have any other lead. Random voting will take us absolutely nowhere.
 
In this game, there is no mafia. Your enemies are anyone who is not on your house, so random voting will 70% help you to be honest.
 
About leads, here is what I gathered so far:

Lycanthropy: Is 100% Joffrey
Cosmic: Saw this thread but didn't post, which was suspicious. He can be anyone.
Sonata: Seemed to want Joffrey dead no matter what, so there's just little chance he's Jaime.

And I'm not saying that Sonata is Jaime, just saying he has a higher chance to be Jaime than anyone so far.
 
I agree wholeheartedly with Mana. This is my first Mafia game, not to mention Klippy took it to the next level - so I'm not really sure I know what I'm doing. T_T

But again, Mana is right - numbers in each person's house is definitely a big factor. We can take out Lycan and House Lannister is down 1 person. Obviously we miss the chance at getting lucky and snagging an early White Walker kill - but this helps all the other houses (as well as peasants make a decision as to which house they join).

As for Jaime getting the kill - that's the exact same as all of us bandwagoning to kill 1 random when it comes to this early in the game, right? So we have a choice between killing a lannister and getting 1 random kill (from Jaime) -> or we get 1 random kill from some bandwagon-lynching?

For now, with what I've seen, I'm going to stick with [Kill Lycanthropy] but if someone can convince me this logic is wrong, I'll stick to it!

eddit: Seth, I don't think saying "Candy is suspicious and can be anyone" -> doesn't "being anyone" apply to all of us at this point? (With the obvious exception that is Lycan)
 
Not changing how I voted just yet, I can still be persuaded, but just want to point out that whoever Jamie and Cersei are MIGHT be pushing for Joffery to be killed, Tywin and Tyrion might be pushing just as hard to get Lycan not killed. As Mana said, house numbers are important. Soo using the argument that "Sonata: Seemed to want Joffrey dead no matter what, so there's just little chance he's Jaime" could go the other way to say "Seth Collins really wants Joffery kept alive, so there's just a little chance he's Tywin or Tyrion"...

Edit: OR Jamie and Cersei both realize the house numbers are important and don't want Joffery dead atm either. Jamie getting a kill later would be more beneficial when some other roles might be known than a completely random kill currently.
 
Last edited:
Sorry for the above, I think the post got stuck loading and decided to post itself right now, lol.

Anyway, JaDe.X105 is right, it could possibly go both ways.
 
JaDe.X105 said:
Not changing how I voted just yet, I can still be persuaded, but just want to point out that whoever Jamie and Cersei are MIGHT be pushing for Joffery to be killed, Tywin and Tyrion might be pushing just as hard to get Lycan not killed. As Mana said, house numbers are important. Soo using the argument that "Sonata: Seemed to want Joffrey dead no matter what, so there's just little chance he's Jaime" could go the other way to say "Seth Collins really wants Joffery kept alive, so there's just a little chance he's Tywin or Tyrion"...

Edit: OR Jamie and Cersei both realize the house numbers are important and don't want Joffery dead atm either. Jamie getting a kill later would be more beneficial when some other roles might be known than a completely random kill currently.
Click to expand...

That's a possibility also yes, but it still works out just as well really. Then we still see a Lannister die and can keep our eyes out for a possible Jaime/Cersie without activating the revenge kill.
 
[Kill] Bardothren

Wait, wait, wait - no, I don't think you should actually die, but I don't think having my vote here is going to harm you in the slightest. Lycanthropy is definitely going to die today, but I don't want any part of it, and I certainly don't want to start a bandwagon to kill someone else that may be in my house.

If people start latching onto you, I will change my vote. But I'm thinking Klippy will get pissed if we vote for ourselves and essentially abstain, so I'm gonna go with a safe option until more info pops up in this thread, and how people react.

But I think it'd be wasting the hell out of Dany's ability if we killed Lycan now.​
 
Hi. Sorry fir the lack of activity, but my wifi has been non-functioning, and I have no idea. So I won't be around much for the next few days. I'm sorry.
 
To appease our Maester (why isn't he a Grand Maester????) I think I will follow suit with
[Kill] Kiyoshi

same as what you said, nothing against you, but at least I'm not voting myself now.
 
Ullion said:
I agree wholeheartedly with Mana. This is my first Mafia game, not to mention Klippy took it to the next level - so I'm not really sure I know what I'm doing. T_T

But again, Mana is right - numbers in each person's house is definitely a big factor. We can take out Lycan and House Lannister is down 1 person. Obviously we miss the chance at getting lucky and snagging an early White Walker kill - but this helps all the other houses (as well as peasants make a decision as to which house they join).

As for Jaime getting the kill - that's the exact same as all of us bandwagoning to kill 1 random when it comes to this early in the game, right? So we have a choice between killing a lannister and getting 1 random kill (from Jaime) -> or we get 1 random kill from some bandwagon-lynching?

For now, with what I've seen, I'm going to stick with [Kill Lycanthropy] but if someone can convince me this logic is wrong, I'll stick to it!

eddit: Seth, I don't think saying "Candy is suspicious and can be anyone" -> doesn't "being anyone" apply to all of us at this point? (With the obvious exception that is Lycan)
Click to expand...

What? I never said anything about Candy, I was talking about Cosmic. He saw this thread and didn't post, I find that suspicious since most people that can kill someone during night phase don't post during the day that much and people that have less important roles like peasants or anything like that post during the day phase more often. And when I said "anyone" I was talking about the Game of Thrones characters, for example Joffrey, Jaime, Dany...

JaDe.X105 said:
Not changing how I voted just yet, I can still be persuaded, but just want to point out that whoever Jamie and Cersei are MIGHT be pushing for Joffery to be killed, Tywin and Tyrion might be pushing just as hard to get Lycan not killed. As Mana said, house numbers are important. Soo using the argument that "Sonata: Seemed to want Joffrey dead no matter what, so there's just little chance he's Jaime" could go the other way to say "Seth Collins really wants Joffery kept alive, so there's just a little chance he's Tywin or Tyrion"...

Edit: OR Jamie and Cersei both realize the house numbers are important and don't want Joffery dead atm either. Jamie getting a kill later would be more beneficial when some other roles might be known than a completely random kill currently.
Click to expand...

So? I mean, you're right but, think. What's the best thing we can do right now? Is to kill Jaime. Because if we kill him, Cersei dies too. So killing them is the way to go.

I'm asking you to think again. just think. I honestly don't know why people are voting for Lycanthropy. It's going to be a waste, not because Jaime can kill someone, but because we can just kill Lycanthropy when there are no Lannisters left. And I'm laughing at those who underestimate Jaime, like Mana "Jaime can't do anything, he just has one kill". Well, then he's probably going to kill you then. Rofl.
 
Last edited:
Yeah sure, I know i can be wrong, there's no problem with that.

Oh and Jade, you thought that I was Tywin or Tyrion right? Well,

[kill] Lycanthropy

i can kill him and i have no problem killing him. i just want what's best for us all, and you know what I want. I just thought wasting Dany's ability when we can easily ditch Lycanthropy later is a really bad move but seriously, I can vote for him if i want to
 
Rng vote anyone?

I'm sticking with my vote, remember kids, Jaime can only kill one person, and that means we get two out either way, if we target Jaime ore Lycan.
 
I already said that but since you guys are too lazy to read my post, theeeere ya go:

Don't say that Jaime is not dangerous just because he can kill only one person. If you do, he's probably killing you then. Just saying.
 
Seth Rollins said:
Oh and Jade, you thought that I was Tywin or Tyrion right?
Click to expand...

I didn't say you were, I was just saying your argument against Sonata being Jamie had as much validity as you being Tywin or Tyrion. about 2/35 chance.

And I agree that Killing Jamie or Cersei first would be a safe plan to avoid Jamie's revenge kill for Joffery, but how do we go about killing Jamie or Cersei? If they can be taken out then go for it, but claiming that someone who wants Joffery dead today is Jamie or Cersei doesn't have much basis is all I'm getting at.
 
I'll [Kill] Lycanthropy too. I think this is the best course of action.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top