Grand Idea Mafia - A Grand Finish

[gimmepie]

quick question

what was the name of your original role that allowed you to be such a copycat

Apparently, the Town Placeholder.

 

[Pecilia]

48 hours remain and still haven't decided who to vote on. This game rn is a mess to figure out.

 

[gimmepie]

48 hours remain and still haven't decided who to vote on. This game rn is a mess to figure out.

My thoughts exactly.

 

[Klippy]

I think we are at information overload unfortunately. :/ I hate to make this suggestion, but our time is running out here. I think Decidueye's role is the most dangerous in terms of ability right now. His switching ability makes it nearly impossible to determine who is mafia or town because the switching will constantly change and rotate and it also hurts town's ability to accurately investigate people if they just get swapped with or swap to another role.

So how would we feel about Decidueye today? It's the only other choice we have today besides randomly selecting one of us pairs of twin roles if all four of us are being truthful. My gut says it's impossible because we are so few in numbers, but if Pecilia, EC, gimme, Johnny, and myself are all innocent (based on our role reveals), plus Naku, Gunner, and the poem member (sorry I can't recall your username and I'm on mobile) were confirmed inno right? That leaves Nero, Decidueye, and possibly one or two others right? I can't see the member list ATM but I'll update this post after I'm able to look back if needed.

Edit: Selena for poem member and NightKrow is the other member still in the game.

 

[EC]

Getting rid of the role switcher might indeed be the best bet, and then go from there.

 

[gimmepie]

Something sounds kind of sketchy about that tbh...
In saying that, Decidueye could still be the mafia couldn't he?

 

[NightKrow]

So it looks like myself and Nero are the only ones left who haven't claimed, and then Decidueye could be a mafia-sided switching role. I'll agree that the switching is definitely detrimental to town at this point, and there's a chance Decidueye could be mafia or even third party. Could be an Old Maid style thing.

Might as well get the ball rolling and [Vote] Decidueye.

I reckon now would probably be a good time for me to claim. I'm a chocolate-flavoured townie, in a similar way that Rabi was a s'mores-flavoured townie, except I don't have an extra part to my role so I do nowt. Just my luck that in a game where I could've had any weird and wonderful role, I'm stuck with a vanilla chocolate townie :(
At least I'm chocolate-flavoured I guess, and not boring ol' vanilla.

 

[Pecilia]

Yea I feel that lynching Decidueye is the best call right now.

[Vote] Decidueye

 

[Klippy]

Something sounds kind of sketchy about that tbh...
In saying that, Decidueye could still be the mafia couldn't he?

What makes it sketchy? I'm genuinely curious. I feel like it makes the most sense to protect our own roles and ensure claimed innocents/proven innocents remain that way. For example, if he had swapped Naku, but Naku never said and swapped himself with another, we've now lost track of our once-proven inno. Just my feelings on it. And there is still the chance he's mafia, but at this point I think the first reasoning is more sound overall...

[VOTE] Decidueye

 

[gimmepie]

What makes it sketchy? I'm genuinely curious. I feel like it makes the most sense to protect our own roles and ensure claimed innocents/proven innocents remain that way. For example, if he had swapped Naku, but Naku never said and swapped himself with another, we've now lost track of our once-proven inno. Just my feelings on it. And there is still the chance he's mafia, but at this point I think the first reasoning is more sound overall...

[VOTE] Decidueye

Okay, I'm sold.

[VOTE] Decidueye

 

[EC]

Making my vote official.

[VOTE] Decidueye

 

[Salzorrah]

Yeah Ill follow

[vote] Decidueye

 

[Nero]

Eh, fine. [Vote] Decidueye
I could prove my innocence by using my action tonight, actually. I'm not that worried if mafia target me because of it.

 

[Nakuzami]

Where is Superjolt when you need to punch a guy in the neck

Vote Decidueye

 

[ddrox13]

How about we kill the guy who BLOCKED my role switch? Keep in mind that the Mafia likely has my kill from earlier, and intentionally voting a claimed someone who killed TWO mafia seems...

Like it would make me very sad :(

Anywho, so ends my defense. Have fun with yet another non-mafia lynch if you'd like. Not like I care or anything.

[Vote] Goku

 

[gimmepie]

Decidueye the tsundere

 

[Superjolt]

Something happened!

Suddenly, gimmepie was punched in the neck (by a bullet)!

He's now dead as fuck!

gimmepie was a Mafia Placeholder!
​

-
gimmepie's Role PM:

Spoiler:

Welcome to Grand Idea Mafia, gimmepie!

You are a Mafia Placeholder

Factional Kill: You must choose which player carries out the night kill. Choosing to do a no-kill is a valid option.

Abilities:
- Place Now Held (Passive): You are not affected by the first action that targets you
- Re-Do: You gain a copy of the first action that targets you

Win Condition: You win when all opposing factions are outnumbered or eliminated and at least 1 mafia-aligned player is still alive, or if nothing can prevent this.

 

[Superjolt]

All votes have been reset! Deadline also extended!

Vote Count 5.2

Currently Not Voting (10): Superjolt, NightKrow, Johnny, Pecilia, Selena Fluorspar, Nero, EvilChameleon, Klippy, Decidueye, Nakuzami

With 10 players alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch!

The day now ends in 39 hours, around 3:30pm EST on Tuesday, May 2nd.

GM Notes:
- For extra extra clarification:

- Should also probably mention cuz of a possible question I got: roles are not 100% guaranteed to be the alignment listed in a post in the Grand Idea thread

 

[Nakuzami]

Something happened!

Suddenly, gimmepie was punched in the neck (by a bullet)!

He's now dead as fuck!

gimmpie was a Mafia Placeholder!
​

I did ask for his consent, did I not

you're welcome

 

[EC]

Well that's certainly an interesting twist. Do we need to do another five posts?