His Return [House Points awarded!]

[ジュナイパー]

The vertiserum sounds like a good idea.
[Banish] no one

Didn't Mana say we couldn't vote for this "Mr. No One" anymore? If we can't, who will we banish?

 

[Nimsy]

hm. . .I need the Ravenclaws to give their reports, even inno reports will be useful.

 

[Salzorrah]

Hmmm well, we don't have any leads other than catman claiming so

[banish] alexkaz61

 

[Sun]

[Banish] alexkaz61

It is impossible for Alex to be Professor Snape. I know who is the real Professor Snape and I have my ways to know who it is, Alex. Snape does NOT have any special spells too, the end. Don't challenge me or I'm taking you down tonight.


Now, be a good boy and reveal your role before you die. Or I'm sticking my wand in your butt.

What role do ghosts even play in this game? They can't really die and it's not like they exactly have alignments, do they?

My friend, you will need these.

Hmmm well, we don't have any leads other than catman claiming so

[banish] alexkaz61

So far I see no problem with Piepie and Cat's words. Their words are our best leads for the time being.

 

[Nimsy]

Okay, so by guessing I assume there are:
6 Gryffindors
6 Slytherins
6 Ravenclaws
5 Hufflepuffs
5 death eaters
1 other

Each house having 5 students and one house head.

 

[gimmepie]

Sun, how exactly are you so sure about all this?

 

[Nimsy]

Wait, I just remembered:
"Legilimens - Allows the caster to delve into the mind of the victim, allowing the caster to detect their alignment."

It wouldn't be based off the mark, but their true intentions.

 

[Nakuzami]

To be fair, we all also speculated to a fair extent about the existence of Snape in the game and his possible status as a double agent, making it incredibly easy for a mafia member to claim as it and find at least a few people that would believe such a claim.

Not saying he's lying, but he also very well could be.

Also, I think gimmepie is pretty much clear at this point. He could have been lying about the Imperio curse, but he wouldn't really be able to make up Mana's post about the Fiendfyre. Along with that, I think it's possible that the mafia—hopefully realizing that manipulating a vote in the early phases isn't going to help a lynch—cursed pie twice with Kiyo as a target so that they could try and hit him with a Fiendfyre, that would at least be almost guaranteed to be activated, even if it didn't end up succeeding. Because of that, I'm willing to bet on Kiyobae's innocence for the time being as well.

I'm actually a Ravenclaw. I used Legilimency on Alex and one other person that isn't in this conversation (but I can assure you, they're with Hogwarts). The only reason that I revealed it so early in the phase was because of what Nimsy said.

And catman, please state the inno hit you got with your investigation. Now that you've claimed as a Ravenclaw, there's no reason to hold any relevant information back, and eliminating an inno from a list of possible lynchees is still fairly useful in its own right. Of course, that could open up a confirmed inno to an attack from the Death Eaters, but we should still have plenty of Hufflepuffs to use Apaneo right now anyways.

Also, @gimmepie - as Nimsy said, she guessed—she doesn't actually know that that's the spread, lol. I assume she just took the number of players in the game and divided it in a way that the Hogwarts Houses would be even, and the Death Eaters would be a relatively fair size as well.

and @Sun - I'm not going to go against your claim to knowing who Snape is—you could be him yourself, or somehow have gotten the information otherwise, though I doubt the latter since all regular students have the same sets of spells. What I do question is why Snape wouldn't have a special ability. All House Heads do, and Death Eaters have their own dark spells. It doesn't seem reasonable that Snape wouldn't have other spells.

Though I do wonder why all Slytherins can use Sectumsempra. I would have thought that would be a Snape only spell, since he created it and, to my knowledge, Harry is the only other person that has used it.

 

[Alex Kaz]

[Banish] alexkaz61

It is impossible for Alex to be Professor Snape. I know who is the real Professor Snape and I have my ways to know who it is, Alex. Snape does NOT have any special spells too, the end. Don't challenge me or I'm taking you down tonight.


Now, be a good boy and reveal your role before you die. Or I'm sticking my wand in your butt

Do you dare cc me Sunny? That is not a smart move. I may have to Langlock you tonight, and I wouldn't wanna do this to you. I was thinking of other ways to use your tongue.

 

[Sun]

snip

Spell =/= Ability for me. :P Yeah, screw me for using my Pokemon logics.

I was thinking of other ways to use your tongue.

Not here, not here. ;) ;) ;)

Sun, how exactly are you so sure about all this?

You mean about Snape's identity or Alex lying?

If you are referring to the latter one, well I'm not actually so sure. But when it comes to the first one... Hmm, you are smart enough to figure why am I aware of Snape's real identity.

Wow, uh. I think I'll believe what Sun said, I'm not too sold on alexkaz61 being Snape.

But before I vote, can I ask how do you know about this, Sun?

Because, I know it. Cheap riddle time: Look in the mirror and you'll find your answer.

 

[ジュナイパー]

And catman, please state the inno hit you got with your investigation. Now that you've claimed as a Ravenclaw, there's no reason to hold any relevant information back, and eliminating an inno from a list of possible lynchees is still fairly useful in its own right. Of course, that could open up a confirmed inno to an attack from the Death Eaters, but we should still have plenty of Hufflepuffs to use Apaneo right now anyways.

Alright then, if you say so. Lycanthropy is sided with Hogwarts.

 

[Alex Kaz]

To be fair, we all also speculated to a fair extent about the existence of Snape in the game and his possible status as a double agent, making it incredibly easy for a mafia member to claim as it and find at least a few people that would believe such a claim.

Would you think I mentioned Snape yesterday because I foresaw a Hufflepuff investigating me? Or I just hinted you who I am? What makes more sense?

 

[Sun]

Oh, are we talking about a magic mirror inside Hogwarts?

Just trust me like how you trust Blarzigord.

 

[Nathan]

why did we trust catman so quickly tho?

 

[Nakuzami]

Alright then, if you say so. Lycanthropy is sided with Hogwarts.

Ah, yes, well, I knew that a while ago, and then it changed . . . and then Lycan died. So I guess that bit of info was rather irrelevant. Better to know what your target was, though.

 

[Klippy]

There's a lot of claims going on. :|

Snape/alex being a double agent is 100% backed up by canon. It's literally who he is in the books. Whether alex is telling the truth, however, who knows. It'd be really bad if we lost a second House Head though given our already being down one, so I'd seriously think about targeting someone else if another option is viable.

Sun is being suspicious though honestly. He's throwing out a ton of weird ass statements and threats. Either he's Snape or he's not. We need to know if he's CCing though.

 

[GlendleYoung]

oh god im finally, sorta, caught up. I like the idea of a ravenclaw using veritaserum on alex but not being able to no lynch i am reluctant to send in my vote but just incase i can't get back (busy night tonight) here it is

[banish] Alex

S0z

 

[Sun]

Sun is being suspicious though honestly. He's throwing out a ton of weird ass statements and threats. Either he's Snape or he's not. We need to know if he's CCing though.

I'm disappointed.

 

[Wicked3DS]

Sun plz

 

[Klippy]

That's fine, but it still doesn't answer the weird back-and-forth we're witnessing between you two. Just say how you know so we can fully render a decision. Otherwise there should be another avenue explored.