• Just a reminder that providing specifics on, sharing links to, or naming websites where ROMs can be accessed is against the rules. If your post has any of this information it will be removed.
  • Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Our weekly protagonist poll is now up! Vote for your favorite Trading Card Game 2 protagonist in the poll by clicking here.
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Map Rating/Review Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
I got two map.

Map name : ---(Still thinking)
Map :
Spoiler:


Map name : ---
Map :
Spoiler:


Credit : CheesePeow for the rombase.

Pls rate and comment.
 
ShineGreymOn -
1st map - This is a very well done map, I can see nothing wrong with it. I like the way the river flows in the middle.

2nd map - A basic route, but done very nicely. The only thing I don't like is that it looks just like Route 1 from Fire Red, but I don't know if you did that on purpose or not.
 
ShineGreymΘn said:
I got two map.

Map name : ---(Still thinking)
Map :
Spoiler:


Map name : ---
Map :
Spoiler:


Credit : CheesePeow for the rombase.

Pls rate and comment.
Click to expand...

9/10
Okay in the maps not too many problems actually here's a few:
The grass sprites are all same.
With the trees the all look a little square boxed in you a little unnatural imo.
This goes espicially with the grass it's all so square i mean is someone tending the grass I don't think so, make it more erractic to give it more of a natural feel.
The little trees by the house in town look really out of place.
Remember 75% of nature is natural and wild not contained and neat.
Hope i helped :3
 
Uh..well, I got a map...for rating...
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

It's the first route!
 
dark lakitu said:
Uh..well, I got a map...for rating...
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

It's the first route!
Click to expand...
Rating: 8.5/10
Reason: It's a very nice route map. Looks very elegant and simple, and it looks like a very good first route. The patches of grass are placed in a nice simple way. The only thing that bothers me is that you can go across the whole route without meeting a single pokemon. That's a negative thing for a route. Some places are empty. Else, the map looks really nice.
Suggestions: Just improve it as I've stated above.
 
Nothing reli just a starter town.

Map Name: Pilot Town
Map:
Spoiler:
 
Here's a Random map.
Info: The house has a bike shop behind it because it those people own the bike shop.
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread
 
Eeveon said:
Here's a Random map.
Info: The house has a bike shop behind it because it those people own the bike shop.
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread
Click to expand...
Unless the house is story-needed, it doesn't "need" to be in the game, does it? Are you going to put in Nurse Joy's house behind every PC? And the Mart attendant's houses? It's only fair. :paranoid:

Anyway, if you're bound on keeping it, logically, would you want people walking through your house to get to your business? I'd switch them around. Besides that, the rest of the route is pretty boring, unless there's a reason there's no wild grass. Seems to me that flowers are a tad over-used too.

6/10
 
ShineGreymΘn said:
Map name : ---(Still thinking)
Map :
Spoiler:
Click to expand...
Rating: 6/10
Urgh, another person using that rom base. No offense to the creator, its just soooo overused. Well, anyway, the map is a little boring. Try using different tiles for the houses, those ones are a little too generic. Tree placement isn't bad but not great. I like the stream going through the town but I don't like its shape. Bad flower placement and the thickness changing of the paths is a little weird. I also don't like the big building, use different building tiles.

ShineGreymΘn said:
Map name : ---
Map :
Spoiler:
Click to expand...
Rating: 8/10
Pretty decent use of ledges, something a lot of people find hard. Good placement of flowers too. The only big problem I have is the path thickness once again. Try to keep it uniform, it looks much better.

dark lakitu said:
Uh..well, I got a map...for rating...
Spoiler:

It's the first route!
Click to expand...
Rating: 7.5/10
Not bad, its definitely a good looking map. Use of trees is excellent. Ledges are ok, but some are redundant. It looks a bit empty as well.

Eeveon said:
Here's a Random map.
Info: The house has a bike shop behind it because it those people own the bike shop.
Spoiler:
Click to expand...
Rating: 5/10
The paths look great! It's the rest of the stuff that lets it down. Why use the skinny trees as the border? Looks weird, use the big trees instead. Limit the amount of skinny trees to under 5 in the map. Waaay too many flowers and shrubs. Use big trees instead of shrubs to surround the bike shop. Also, its just plain weird to have a bike shop in a route isn't it?

Quilava's Master said:
Nothing reli just a starter town.

Map Name: Pilot Town
Map:
Spoiler:
Click to expand...
Rating: 6/10
Another rom base? Urrgh. It's not too bad. The paths and 3 different house types looks weird. So does the different colored mail boxes. A single flower? Use some more. Its just kind of a boring map, its not bad just boring.
 
Last edited:
Map Name: Route 1
Comments: This is a map form my game, Pokémon Zephyr.
Map:
Spoiler:
 
TD: WOW :O ive seen ur maps b4,and their great,but this is just awesome. 8.5/10 i like how u used little grass and flowers to brighten it up :) the cave looks like...realish :O with the rocks and everything wat idont like it that u can get lost very easily and theres a few 2 many trees 4 my liking. Nice job altogther,tho.

Here's my map, again, a route for my game. It isn't so great, just a simple remake of the first route in FR but i like it.
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread
 
Map Name: Washington Town
This is for my first series of Pokemon Chronicles. Thanks to X-Buster for the Rom Base.
 
Momoko said:
TD: WOW :O ive seen ur maps b4,and their great,but this is just awesome. 8.5/10 i like how u used little grass and flowers to brighten it up :) the cave looks like...realish :O with the rocks and everything wat idont like it that u can get lost very easily and theres a few 2 many trees 4 my liking. Nice job altogther,tho.

Here's my map, again, a route for my game. It isn't so great, just a simple remake of the first route in FR but i like it.
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread
Click to expand...
Big problem here, you have 3 DIFFERENT types of paths in ONE map! It doesn't work like that. The path has to be continous, otherwise it just looks bad.
There are a few tile errors, and plainly, the player can get through the map whilst only walking through 5 tiles of grass. That is just not right.
5/10
Rescue Team Wave said:
Map Name: Washington Town
This is for my first series of Pokemon Chronicles. Thanks to X-Buster for the Rom Base.
Click to expand...
Hmm, 3/10. You've used one whole ledge as a staircase.
All your houses are in one line and not even seperate.
There is no constant borderblock.
The paths are too wide.
it needs quite a bit of work.
 
Not a big fan of the maps I have been seeing. Some people need to be grilled. Starting now I will be critiquing new maps.

Rigght now I am here to present a map from my new hack.

[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread


Tile error in bottom left.

edit: mart area s grassy cause old poor man lives there and does not keep to it
 
I just finished making this island.

Spoiler:
sorry for small image. I put the whole thing on one map, as when I had 9 maps for the whole island, the connections kept messing up :/
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top