Map Rating/Review Thread

[johnlycett]

Ok i would like my maps to be rated please look in spoiler

Spoiler:

 

[Zanacross]

Meh i dont like the tiles and pallets

the just dont appeal to me

meh

7/10

 

[Erimgard]

hey johnlycet, I give it an 8/10

There are quite a few mapping errors in the first picture (treetops cut off and such)

 

[Geeked]

@johnlycett
in the second one theres a small tile error on the roof of the house with the red roof
1st map:7/10
second: 8/10
third: it looks 2 much like the first one so 6/10

 

[destinedjagold]

@johnlycett
I like the maps and the colors of both the grass and the trees. I also like the houses....., but as they say, there's a tiny bit of error ya got there.

Overall, 7/10. ;)

 

[cooley]

Starting city in my hack.

Glistern Town
Sorry for not following the thread requirements/format for posting, no time.
-cooley

DO NOT STEAL MY PALETTES!!!!

Unknown City in my hack.
Ideas, would be nice.

DO NOT STEAL MY PALETTES!!!!

 

[destinedjagold]

amazingly well made, cooley! You are a great pallete editor!

I like the flowers that stands out in the map. They are very looking soooooo cute. :)

I see no tile errors whatsoever, but those little bushes and small rocks kinda annoys me, for they are taking a lot of spaces in the map.

Anyways, overall.., 9/10 ;)

 

[Lady Berlitz]

Yeah, you're maps are amazing, Cooley. I just think (like DJG said) that the rocks are annoying me... the bushes are fine, but the rocks' sequence make me think there's a bit too much. And maybe you can change the flowers that are by the signpost into a different type of line, they look like a cross...

 

[Ranger Dude]

This isn't my best,

but Its supposed to be a recreation of Phenac City of the Gamecube:



What do you guys think?

 

[destinedjagold]

I can see that you are using Emerald. Nice And I like the map.

7/10

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

@ Cooley
Your maps look great but I think the palettes from the rocks and the grass don't match...
And the colors from the flowers are a little to bright because the rest op the palette colors are a little dark like and then the flowers are neon blue..XD but the overall is nice so I think....7/10

and the second one is the same but it has to much open spaces..so I think overall 6.5/10

@ Ranger Dude
It looks nice but it has something that I don't like I can't describe it... so I think a 7/10...

 

[Binary]

Cooley--Wow nice mate! I love the first map, i could make adjustmens to it since im
your mapper anyways--8/10
2nd map-7.5/10
Rangerdude--I love the map, good creation mate--7/10

 

[cooley]

Thanks for comments guys. It means a lot.
-cooley

 

[Geeked]

@ranger dude hm.. theres a few things i dont like about that map but who am i to judge?... anyways 6.5/10

@cooley
i like the starter town also nice palletes
1st:8/10
2nd:9/10 you really did that one good!


Also nobody rated my maps please rate them please!!!:

thanks ill try to fix those errors

Heres a few more maps

These are a few maps i did since my hack will not only include my region but the hoenn also

the route to oldale

Oldale:

Littleroot:

 

[cooley]

They are pretty good, for a remake of hoenn.
ALL: 8/10 ;) :^) ^_^ I think you should use something else for the Lab tile.
-cooley

 

[destinedjagold]

@ yung stunna..,

they are fire red tiles, right, but I can see it's a perfect remake of the hoenn region maps. Nice :) Overall, 7.8/10

- edited -

I agree with cooley about the lab.

 

[♠εx]

I've got two maps here, i've made them links due to their size.

First Town:


First Route:

 

[destinedjagold]

Well, I like the maps so far. :)

Overall, 8/10

 

[loitraitim]

Wow...this Map of cooley is very cool ^^
Map 1: 8.3/10
Map 2: 8/10

Have fun ^^ (Vietnamese - Toi la nguoi Viet Nam)

 

[Geeked]

That will mean i'll have to change the houses 2 ill think about it

btw does anybody want to join the staff of my game?