Map Rating/Review Thread

[destinedjagold]

INTRO: Hi pipz! Phew... I'm pooped... xD
MAP NAME: TEAM Base (I think...)
BASE GAME: POKéMON Ruby U.S. Version ROM
HACK FOR: Our team's next hack project. ;)
COMMENT: The tiles aren't my best work. I'm not a tiler, by the way. xD Oh well... And also, this map's not finished yet. But I want it to be rated. And also... Don't steal the tiles...
MAP:

Spoiler:

I know... It's empty... If ya read my comment, you should know that the map's not complete yet. :)

 

[ShineGreymΘn]

Hello all!
Base Game:Fire Red
Map Name:No yet..
Comment:Err.. nothing can say..
Judgement: Rate, Comment and Suggestions.
Map:

Spoiler:

I hope it better than before.

 

[Binary]

Ahhh DJG, nice map, the tiles are also good, but the only thing is that the map looks squarish :\ And since you haven't finished it, I won't rate it yet :P

Hello all!
Base Game:Fire Red
Map Name:No yet..
Comment:Err.. nothing can say..
Judgement: Rate, Comment and Suggestions.
Map:

Spoiler:

I hope it better than before.

Rate:6/10
Reason: The map looks nice, except for a few errors in the paths. The map is quite squarish and abit plain, you could've added some greenery.
Suggestion: Don't make the map too much square and try to add alot of greenery. Try to give the map some liveliness, and don't make it too plain.

Map name: Felridge City
Base Game: Pokemon Fire Red
Hacked Game: Pokemon Genesis
Judgement: Rate, Comment and Suggestions.

Spoiler:

Map name: Temshore City
Base Game: Pokemon Fire Red
Hacked Game: Pokemon Genesis
Judgement: Rate, Comment and Suggestions.

Spoiler:

Map 1:
Rate: 8/10
Reason: Wow, I love the greenness in the map, makes it look good, and the tiles are great, Nice work!
Suggestion: The map looks so good, it dosen't need a suggestion XD I could only see one minor error on the map, in the mountain, so look at for mistakes!

Map 2:
Rate:6.5/10
Reason: Not so good as the previous map, but looks alright. The sand part is abit empty.
Suggestion: Don't make some parts of your maps empty, no other suggestion.....

Have a nice day!

~C3LEBI

 

[ShineGreymΘn]

Hello all!Is me again!
Base Game:Fire Red
Map Name:Slateport City
Comment:Anyway,i am begginer mapper,hope you will like it. ^^
Judgement: Rate, Comment and Suggestions.
Map:

Spoiler:

 

[luke]

Name: Nero Town
Base ROM: Fire Red
Hack: Piratite (Side project of mine)

Spoiler:

Name: Hermit Forest
Base ROM: Fire Red
Hack: Piratite

Spoiler:

Yeah, I'm relatively new to hacking. I'm only now getting this mapping thing down. It's the only thing I can really do at the moment. I don't know if I'll get any further than mapping because I have no other help. But mapping is fun. Please point out dumb errors. Thanks.

 

[Kristian]

Map name: Route 31 (Twiiiiiist)
Base Game: FireRed
Hack: Pyrope
comment: I made this map a while ago..but I just wanted to know what u guys think of it..
so please rate, and give suggestions for improvement.
Im sorry the poor quality, i saved it as a jps file..:o
Map:

Spoiler:

Credits:
GC, PHO - Ripped tree tile
Don Patch, PHO - Mountain Tile
rest is done by me..

thanks! :D

 

[destinedjagold]

Hello all!Is me again!
Base Game:Fire Red
Map Name:Slateport City
Comment:Anyway,i am begginer mapper,hope you will like it. ^^
Judgement: Rate, Comment and Suggestions.
Map:

Spoiler:

Rating: 7/10
Reason: Slateport is a very big city, and wow, you sure made it like one! I like it! :D
Suggestion: I've spotted 2 tile errors there, bud. ;) The 2 errors are to be seen on the lower right corners of the map.
SCREEN ERROR:

Spoiler:

Name: Nero Town
Base ROM: Fire Red
Hack: Piratite (Side project of mine)

Spoiler:

Name: Hermit Forest
Base ROM: Fire Red
Hack: Piratite

Spoiler:

Yeah, I'm relatively new to hacking. I'm only now getting this mapping thing down. It's the only thing I can really do at the moment. I don't know if I'll get any further than mapping because I have no other help. But mapping is fun. Please point out dumb errors. Thanks.

Rating: !st Map--> 8/10 2nd Map--> 9/10
Reason: The 1st map is really coo and very nicely done! Now the second one is cleverly done! I love how the forest looks more realistically made.
Suggestion: The first map, if you play it, you can notice some tile errors there. Fix them up and it'll be a great map. ;)
SCREEN ERROR:

Spoiler:

And there are lots of mountain-edge tile errors. I think from this screeny, you can get the idea. :D

Map name: Route 31 (Twiiiiiist)
Base Game: FireRed
Hack: Pyrope
comment: I made this map a while ago..but I just wanted to know what u guys think of it..
so please rate, and give suggestions for improvement.
Im sorry the poor quality, i saved it as a jps file..:o
Map:

Spoiler:

Credits:
GC, PHO - Ripped tree tile
Don Patch, PHO - Mountain Tile
rest is done by me..

thanks! :D

Rating: 8/10
Reason: I love the grass colour and I love the trees.
Suggestion: No suggestions. ;)

 

[TB Pro]

Here's a map for ya'!

Name: JASTRAL TOWN
ROM: Fire Red
Hack: Secret Wishes
Comment: Well none really lol
Map:

Spoiler:

Credits:
- Don Patch and PHO: Tiles
- Crashink: ROMBase
- Me: lulz all other stuff

 

[+Sneasel™]

Rating: 9/10
Comments: I love the map and the tiles! Those houses look amazing!
Suggestions: Not much, but there are tile errors where the water's edge is. Also, those trees (like the one next to the red house on the right) look weird, since half of it is light and half of it is dark.

 

[Avatar_Aang]

First I would like to add that I am trying to change most of the tiles. So I am not finished. The wild grass is just temporary. Also, due to an error that happened for reason I don't know some tiles don't work. I will edit them soon because it is fixable. So here we go.

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Pallet Town

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Route 21

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Route 1

 

[+Sneasel™]

First I would like to add that I am trying to change most of the tiles. So I am not finished. The wild grass is just temporary. Also, due to an error that happened for reason I don't know some tiles don't work. I will edit them soon because it is fixable. So here we go.

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Pallet Town

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Route 21

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Route 1

First map
Rating: 5/10
Reasons: Empty, small, and nothing too special about it...

Second map
Rating: 2/10
Reasons: Wayyyyyyyyyyy too many headbutt trees and flowers.

Third map
Rating: 1/10
Reasons: All it is is ledges with grass!

 

[Avatar_Aang]

The l

First map
Rating: 5/10
Reasons: Empty, small, and nothing too special about it...

Second map
Rating: 2/10
Reasons: Wayyyyyyyyyyy too many headbutt trees and flowers.

Third map
Rating: 1/10
Reasons: All it is is ledges with grass!

The last 2 I can understand but... NO FLIPPING DUH THE FIRST ONE IS EMPTY AND SMALL! ITS THE STARTER TOWN >_>

Thanks though XD

Edit: Route 1 in the game is just ledges and grass too >_>

I am editing them though

 

[TB Pro]

First I would like to add that I am trying to change most of the tiles. So I am not finished. The wild grass is just temporary. Also, due to an error that happened for reason I don't know some tiles don't work. I will edit them soon because it is fixable. So here we go.

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Pallet Town

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Route 21

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Route 1

Map 1
Rating: 4.5/10
Reason: Very empty. Very bland and plain. Seems like an abandoned camp....
Suggestions: Add more livelyness to it, Make it look like someone actually lives there! Make something actually go on there.

Map 2
Rating: 1.5/10
Reason: So many headbutt trees and flowers. >.<
Suggestions: Remove many headbutt trees and flowers. Remember Flowers are only supposed to be diagonal to eachother not side-by-side. Add more of a natural feel to it.

Map 3
Rating: .5/10
Reason: Ugly! Horrid! Ok really now, Way too many ledges in un-natural places. Random grass spots, smallness, and weirdly placed paths.
Suggestions: Remove lots of ledges, Ledges are to be used sparingly. Not to be used willy-nilly as you have done. Place them in a natural pattern. Make the paths blend not just jutt out of nowhere...

All-in-all you need to work on your mapping skills some more,
But your not as bad as some be glad for that!

Also look at the map I posted, That is my starting town.
It looks nice does it not? It's not a bland flavorless map like yours huh?
Try to work on that ok?

Also no you are wrong, ROUTE 1 is actually a good map instead of what you made.
They though carefully about the placement of each ledge where you just slapped them around like they were part of an all-you-can-eat buffet!
Work on that.

 

[Lupe]

map name:balamb town
map game:fire red
comments:redid this map since the first version was terribly horrible

credits:donpatch and pho

 

[kebbles]

map name:balamb town
map game:fire red
comments:redid this map since the first version was terribly horrible

credits:donpatch and pho

Rating: 7.5/10
Reason: The tiles look awesome, exspecially the houses and the lab im guessing? Good mixture of tiles and palettes.
Suggestions: WAY to many paths, just have one joined path that leads to every house and out the town, and there only like 3-4 tile errors, other then that a great map.​

 

[Binary]

map name:balamb town
map game:fire red
comments:redid this map since the first version was terribly horrible

credits:donpatch and pho

Rate:7/10
Reason: The palletes and the tiles look amazing but there were some errors on the side of the river/lake thing....(see suggestions)
Suggestions: Way to many pathways It dosen't look good like that and looks abnormal. The houses are like in a line, make them more scattered. Else everything looks good!

~C3LEBI

 

[Luck]

map name:balamb town
map game:fire red
comments:redid this map since the first version was terribly horrible

credits:donpatch and pho

Rating:7 out of 10
There are errors with the lakes, there are too many paths, the houses have a diagnol pattern.
Suggestion:You could only make one path, make new tiles for the edges on the water,spread the flowers a bit more insteadof putting it in one place.

 

[boynapster]

the colour scheme is very dull whats with all the brown

 

[Luck]

Well i'm a okay at most mapper on fr/lg and i decided on trying to make r/s/e maps.
Here it is and as always rate it from 1 to 10.

Well i tried my best on r/s/e and the cave on the top left is the truffle or berry cave.
The house under it is a berry shop and the other gold roofed house is a small hotel.
the building with supposedly a port roof is a building that transports people by a magnet train.

 

[Avatar_Aang]

Well i'm a okay at most mapper on fr/lg and i decided on trying to make r/s/e maps.
Here it is and as always rate it from 1 to 10.

Well i tried my best on r/s/e and the cave on the top left is the truffle or berry cave.
The house under it is a berry shop and the other gold roofed house is a small hotel.
the building with supposedly a port roof is a building that transports people by a magnet train.

I dont like it. It reminds me too much of lilycove.

6/10