Map Rating/Review Thread

[EJames2100]

Thank you, I'll have a go tonight and hope they'll be good :)

 

[Megiddo-san]

Map Name: Musical Forest

Spoiler:

 

[Tyrantrum]

@megiddo: It's too square and there is too many grass...5.5/10
-----------------------------
Here's my map.

It's for my hack, Pokemon Blizzard™

 

[Ryousha]

@megiddo: It's too square and there is too many grass...5.5/10
-----------------------------
Here's my map.

It's for my hack, Pokemon Blizzard™

You used my rombase *hugs* = D!

OMG, you copied my style, and those extra tile inserts on the bottom :(.

judging by the shape of the trees at the bottom it doesn't rly match.

and grass isn't needed.

8/10

(I knew I should've taken out those extra features, now you're mapping is similiar to mine and neti's!) Bad boy!

 

[FenderX]

@megiddo: It's too square and there is too many grass...5.5/10
-----------------------------
Here's my map.

It's for my hack, Pokemon Blizzard™

Nice, i see you got the snow tiles...you arranged everything nicely and i like how you placed the houses and the path... 8.5/10

P.S.- There is going to be a border problem on top of the house..

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

This is just a small route to get me warmed up to the ice tiles.
I'll take all kinds of CC cept for something that's absolutely ridiculous.
Such as saying "it has too much snow".

 

[Tyrantrum]

Very good, but the right and left side of the mountains r a little empty. :\
Also...Too much snow!...jk, jk! XD
Very good...8.5/10

 

[Ryousha]

Very good, but the right and left side of the mountains r a little empty. :\
Also...Too much snow!...jk, jk! XD
Very good...8.5/10

AGAIN MORE SNOW PEOPLE?

GODS SAKE STOP ASKING DSHAYABUSA FOR THE SNOW >_<!

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
@Dark Lakitu
the tree at the bottom right with the stack of 3 is weird.
7/10

 

[Tyrantrum]

AGAIN MORE SNOW PEOPLE?

GODS SAKE STOP ASKING DSHAYABUSA FOR THE SNOW >_<!

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
@Dark Lakitu
the tree at the bottom right with the stack of 3 is weird.
7/10

U don't have to get so mad! :P
Those r the only good snow tiles/palettes for FR!
------------------------
Here's route 1 for my hack.

 

[Ryousha]

9/10 it's not square it's perfect.

also you guys, stop using snow bases, Before I get in my angry mood like I warned everybody if you use snow tiles.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

U don't have to get so mad! :P
Those r the only good snow tiles/palettes for FR!
------------------------
Here's route 1 for my hack.

Lovely route.
Can't see one distasting thing in it.
9/10

Ryousha, what else do you suggest I do for my extra town, Neti's desert tiles?
I just can't draw tiles for crap.
Well...I could use the Sevii tiles...but...they're in use too...x.x

 

[Tyrantrum]

Thanx for the comments! ^^
Also, it doesn't matter what tiles u use.
He's just a little upset because everywhere he goes he sees snow tiles, and I feel bad for him.
But it's our decision if we use snow tiles or not.

 

[Ryousha]

Yeah look at me, I started off using Dark Era with FR tiles, then changed it to christos pal,

but that didnt change anything until I used tile changes, tile changing isn't hard, just index it, or recolour it to the right pals so it can be inserted.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Are these posts even allowed?
Yeah...I guess it must be annoying...I mean, the only maps on this whole thread are ice ones...x.x
I meant the actual drawing, Ryousha...

 

[Tyrantrum]

Here's the edited Viridian City, now known as: Kira Town in my hack. :)

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

There's a tile error in the corner there.
Other than that, it looks pretty good.
The town's pretty squashed up, so you might want to enlarge it.
I have to admit, I'm sick of ice tiles as well, especially when it's only some of the things iced up.
8/10. It's too squashed...I guess.

 

[Tyrantrum]

Thanx, and I knew about the corner error right when I posted it unfortunately. :\
I'm to lazy to upload it again! :P
Well, It is a little squashed.
I'm always afraid that it will be to empty.
About the ice tiles, I'm using them only for Pokemon Blizzard.

 

[Ryousha]

This is the first town in Dark Crusade.

 

[Lollypop]

This is the first map I've ever made for ratings. Please rate and give comments.



Credit goes to riolu 9 for the wonderful rombase.

EDIT: @Ryousha: The maps great! I can't see any errors! 10/10.

 

[Thrace]

Think I'll start rating maps again and this time I'm going to be very very critical.

Spoiler:

This is the first town in Dark Crusade.

Rating: 5.5/10
Comments: Pretty clever map design in some places, other places look weird. The puddle next to the lake looks strange. Don't really like the palletes either except for the green roof. Way too much empty space and the mountain just looks weird. Don't like the empty houses and the path is pretty standard so no points there.

This is the first map I've ever made for ratings. Please rate and give comments.

Spoiler:

Credit goes to riolu 9 for the wonderful rombase.

EDIT: @Ryousha: The maps great! I can't see any errors! 10/10.

Rating: 0/10
Comments: I said I would be critical. There is really nothing that appeals to me about this map. The palletes are blinding. Those stairs lead up not sideways. The ledges look bad and so do the trees and flowers. And I don't understand why people insist on using that type of ground tile for walkable mountains. It should only be used when you can't walk on it.