Map Rating/Review Thread

[Disturbed]

Thanks :)


Heres a new map it's abit weird but it has something :P

5/10. Reason: Even though I like the tiles, if anybody would read the first post on this thread, we aren't supposed to rate by beauty of tiles. So the only thing left is how square this map is. Nothing really looks naturally placed, there is a bit too many flowers in pots on the bottom, and the houses are not aligned well.

 

[Chimchar 9]

Thanks :)


Heres a new map it's abit weird but it has something :P

this is horrible there are too many houses together its really square it doesnt look like a town but i like the tiles .
and iv think you have messed it up because you were doing good maps untill this comes along.
well i hope i see much better maps from you.
i give this a : 3.6/10
sorry if i was too harsh

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

5/10. Reason: Even though I like the tiles, if anybody would read the first post on this thread, we aren't supposed to rate by beauty of tiles. So the only thing left is how square this map is. Nothing really looks naturally placed, there is a bit too many flowers in pots on the bottom, and the houses are not aligned well.

this is horrible there are too many houses together its really square it doesnt look like a town but i like the tiles .
and iv think you have messed it up because you were doing good maps untill this comes along.
well i hope i see much better maps from you.
i give this a : 3.6/10
sorry if i was too harsh

Lolz :P I thought it would get horrible ratings XD Made it in 5 minutes just wanted to see if people liked this sort of mapping :P And for the people who don't know I really normally don't make this suckish maps :P:P

 

[Tyrantrum]

I re-did the first town, and I think it's a little better. :P

Rate and comment please! :D

 

[TB Pro]

Thanks! I'll post a map with the mountain changed in trees. And yes I changed Some trees ;)
And another map it has no name...

Suggestions: Hm...I really can't think of any! It's a really great map!
Rating: 9.5/10
Comments: The tiles are wonderful! I like the way you used the paths in that map. The double-house is a bit strange.

Thanks :D Wanted to make it less squarish at the end but there wasn't enough space :P
Here is my Valencia revision 2

Suggestions: None
Rating: 10/10
Comments: This map is beautiful, everything looks great! The tiles and palettes add to that even more.

Thank you :D
Thanks to you to :D:D But I made my comeback :P if you search this thread oyu will find alot of my old maps to ;)

Heres a little route..

lolz and now I'm gonna play GRAW 2 :P

Suggestions: Make it a bit bigger.Try to place more trees.
Rating: 9/10
Comments: Looks great! It's just a bit too small, and not enough trees Imo.

My new map.
It may seem bad, I just did it.
Please rate.
Thank you

Don't mind the tile error. I will fix it now. It's between the small tree and mountain(near the icy water).
Thanks.

Suggestions: Make the map larger, Add another level to the mountain, try to take advantage of the space better.
Rating: 8/10
Comments: The overall map is nice, It's just a bit lacking.

Thanks :)
Heres a new map it's abit weird but it has something :P

Suggestions: Make it less symmetrical, get rid of the weird connecting houses, make it less square.
Rating: 2/10
Comments: This map really isn't good at all. I know this isn't your style, so I'm glad about that.

I re-did the first town, and I think it's a little better. :P

Rate and comment please! :D

Suggestions: Try to make it less symmetrical, Use the empty space up better.
Rating: 5/10
Comments: It's too square, symmetrical, ect. Don't take my rating too harsh!

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

I re-did the first town, and I think it's a little better. :P

Rate and comment please! :D

Alright here I go...
The randomisation of the trees is very good but the border is to symertical espacially in the bottom, and the walking paths would look better if you kept them on a even width like now you have 3 tiles then 2 tiles and again 3 tiles so it would look nicer or neater if you change it into 2 2 2 same goes for the upper path the middle area is to big for a walking path if you did it to fill space you should use some fences next to it.. that's it I think...
I rate it a 6.8/10...:)

Ooh and btw it's easier to rate if you save it as .png because .bmp make it a little blurry..

:EDIT:
Here's a new map from me a little route..

 

[Tyrantrum]

Don't worry, I understand your rating! :D

How's this? :)

Spoiler:

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Don't worry, I understand your rating! :D

How's this? :)

Spoiler:

Yes yes looks much better :) The paths are not really as I meant but it looks good this way to :D now I give it a 8/10

 

[TB Pro]

Alright here I go...
The randomisation of the trees is very good but the border is to symertical espacially in the bottom, and the walking paths would look better if you kept them on a even width like now you have 3 tiles then 2 tiles and again 3 tiles so it would look nicer or neater if you change it into 2 2 2 same goes for the upper path the middle area is to big for a walking path if you did it to fill space you should use some fences next to it.. that's it I think...
I rate it a 6.8/10...:)

Ooh and btw it's easier to rate if you save it as .png because .bmp make it a little blurry..

:EDIT:
Here's a new map from me a little route..

Suggestions: Make the mountains cover a wider array of space, Make it less square around the edges.
Rating: 8/10
Comments: The path looks a bit odd.

Don't worry, I understand your rating! :D

How's this? :)

Spoiler:

Suggestions: Egh, make the trees less symmetrical, they are fitted together with the same tile all the way around, change that up.
Rating: 5/10
Comments: Change the path up, it's taking up too much space, change the fitting of the trees. Better, but not great!

 

[Tyrantrum]

Alright here I go...
The randomisation of the trees is very good but the border is to symertical espacially in the bottom, and the walking paths would look better if you kept them on a even width like now you have 3 tiles then 2 tiles and again 3 tiles so it would look nicer or neater if you change it into 2 2 2 same goes for the upper path the middle area is to big for a walking path if you did it to fill space you should use some fences next to it.. that's it I think...
I rate it a 6.8/10...:)

Ooh and btw it's easier to rate if you save it as .png because .bmp make it a little blurry..

:EDIT:
Here's a new map from me a little route..

This map is pretty good too. :)
The only things I don't like is that it's a little too square, and there will be a border problem at the top of the map where the mountain is. :\
Fix those. :mudkip;):
Other than that, it's great. (b'')b
..............................................
7.7/10

 

[Geeked]

Map Name: Ocean View Village
Credits: Alistair, Rock Tiles..
Map Shot:

^Map Name: Route 1^
Credits: Alistair Rock Tiles...
Map Shot: Below, Ocean View Town
Comments: Those are two separate Images

Map Name: Lotar Village(Top of head)
Credits: Alistair, Rock tiles..
Map Shot:

 

[Hiche..]

Map Name: Ocean View Village
Credits: Alistair, Rock Tiles..
Map Shot:

^Map Name: Route 1^
Credits: Alistair Rock Tiles...
Map Shot: Below, Ocean View Town
Comments: Those are two separate Images

Map Name: Lotar Village(Top of head)
Credits: Alistair, Rock tiles..
Map Shot:

Great maps, Xray.
Your mapping is very neat.
In the first town, it's perfect.
The route is great.
Rating: 9.5/10
(I rate the first two together)
third one, it's great, but there is one small tile error(tree attached with mountain tile, there is a black spot)
I like the path.
But over all it's amazing.
Rating: 9.1/10

 

[colcolstyles]

third one, it's great, but there is one small tile error(tree attached with mountain tile, there is a black spot)

That same error occurs four times in the first map as well (check the very bottom).

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Gylly Road

Map Game: FireRed (Neti's RomBase ^^)

Comments: I done this in the last few days Rate it ^_^ Thanks!

Mapshot:

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Map Name: Gylly Road

Map Game: FireRed (Neti's RomBase ^^)

Comments: I done this in the last few days Rate it ^_^ Thanks!

Mapshot:

Looks nice but I don't like the placement of the grass it's to random it would be better to group it a little.. I'll rate it 8.8/10 :)

And a new map from me :)

 

[Hiche..]

Map Name: Gylly Road

Map Game: FireRed (Neti's RomBase ^^)

Comments: I done this in the last few days Rate it ^_^ Thanks!

Mapshot:

This map got potential , but what I don't like are:
The bridges are way sticked together, the grass is put randomly, on the top right you can see the border..
Suggestions: Less grass, more trees, fix up the bridges, design the icy water..
Rating: fix it, then I will give a rating.
(sorry for the harsh comments, but that's just my opinion)

And poke-Roy
Your map is amazing!!
I only dislike the water on the left.
But great map, really!
Rating: 8.6/10

 

[Platinum Lucario]

Looks nice but I don't like the placement of the grass it's to random it would be better to group it a little.. I'll rate it 8.8/10 :)

And a new map from me :)

This map looks nice, let's see how it goes... :\

Tile Errors: I can't really see any tile errors, so it's pretty good so far.

Comments: It looks nice, I'd have to say that it's a nice Tileset. Nothing looks square on this map, good work! :)

Suggestions: What could be good is maybe you could improve the Tileset so it would look nicer. ;)

Rating: Well, this is one of the good maps I've seen so far, so I'd give it a rating of 9.6/10.0!

Well that is a very good rating for that map, but guess what, you almost got 10/10.
Anyway, I'd like to see some better maps that you've made, good luck! :)

 

[Chimchar 9]

name of map : route 1
fire red
please rate this its for the best team here on pc
map:

please rate

 

[.:God:.]

Here ya go guys, this is for Pokemon: Adventures in the Four Continents!
Rate & Review! Thanks!

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Here ya go guys, this is for Pokemon: Adventures in the Four Continents!
Rate & Review! Thanks!

Alright,, The map is to blockish the mountains you have to make more gaps and sticking out rocks (don't know how to say it exactly) and the streets are to big not very bad but it would be prettier if it was a little smaller, it all is to symetrical try make it looking more natural..
Maybe a little harsh but I have to give this map a 5/10