Map Rating/Review Thread

[Disturbed]

I re-did the first town, and I think it's a little better. :P

Rate and comment please! :D

3/10... Reason: Too symmetrical (not art class :D)(Did I spell that right?)(Why so many parenthesis?)(Did I spell that right?) Well, there are no normal trees in the center of the map... except for the honey trees. But there really wouldn't be 2 honey trees next to eachother on the same map would there? The tiles also hurt my eyes, although that does not affect the harsh rating I gave.

Sorry, but at least it ain't square :)

 

[MudMast]

Here ya go guys, this is for Pokemon: Adventures in the Four Continents!
Rate & Review! Thanks!

Rating: 7.5/10

Reason: Great map there, some parts of the mountains seem odd (bottom right), nice idea of having a signpost on a stair (so we can't go straight :D), and I like how the cave is placed there. Though there are a few reasons for it not being a perfect score, like how parts like the cave and etc are too close and cramped, also it's pretty square.

Suggestions: Separate the building-cave, de-square the map, lower the amount of signposts (seriously-three on 1 house?), you dont need to pave everything, leave some plain grass nearer the mountains.

That is all.

 

[Tyrantrum]

3/10... Reason: Too symmetrical (not art class :D)(Did I spell that right?)(Why so many parenthesis?)(Did I spell that right?) Well, there are no normal trees in the center of the map... except for the honey trees. But there really wouldn't be 2 honey trees next to eachother on the same map would there? The tiles also hurt my eyes, although that does not affect the harsh rating I gave.

Sorry, but at least it ain't square :)

Sorry dude, old map. :P
I posted it remade, I'll edit the post. ;)

EDIT: Whoops, forgot I didn't post it. :P
I'll post it later. ;)

 

[Geeked]

Here ya go guys, this is for Pokemon: Adventures in the Four Continents!
Rate & Review! Thanks!

The map doesn't seem to add up much, for starters it's to "Square-ish" It's best to give your Mountains some form of "Style" I've never been a big fan of "Straight Lines" Same goes for your Paths.. The Rock to the right of the lab doesn't make any sense.. There's much more I can say, but I don't want to be too harsh.. 6.3/10

Check out this post to help your rock paths:

For water, jus scribble water around the general area you want the water to be. Tidy it up a little bit so it looks less square, like this:

, then add the finishing touches and you have a pretty good looking sea/river

.


For cliffs, just scatter around the 4 sides of the cliffs all around where you want the cliffs to be, like this:

, then just add the finishing touches, like before, and pretty cool and better looking cliffs.

...

Doing that, you could really help your maps out. If you do that, I will really rate your maps alot higher than before.

Also Hoping my maps can get a few more ratings xP
Map Name: Ocean View Village
Credits: Alistair, Rock Tiles..
Map Shot:

^Map Name: Route 1^
Credits: Alistair Rock Tiles...
Map Shot: Below, Ocean View Town
Comments: Those are two separate Images

Map Name: Lotar Village(Top of head)
Credits: Alistair, Rock tiles..
Map Shot:

 

[TB Pro]

Map Name: Ocean View Village
Credits: Alistair, Rock Tiles..
Map Shot:

^Map Name: Route 1^
Credits: Alistair Rock Tiles...
Map Shot: Below, Ocean View Town
Comments: Those are two separate Images

Map Name: Lotar Village(Top of head)
Credits: Alistair, Rock tiles..
Map Shot:

Map 1:
Suggestions: Maybe change the placing/span of the tall mountain in the center of the map(s). Just looks a bit odd the way it is now. Also, try to randomize the grass a bit now, looks a bit too blocky as it is.
Rating: 8.5/10
Comments: I love the combination of mountains, and houses. I also love how you placed the houses tucked away in recesses of Trees!

Map 2:
Suggestions: Maybe move around/remove the Hedges, Either enlarge or remove the small mountain.
Rating: 8/10
Comments: A really great map! You're very good at making mountainous maps!

Looks nice but I don't like the placement of the grass it's to random it would be better to group it a little.. I'll rate it 8.8/10 :)

And a new map from me :)

Suggestions: Remove some of the planter boxes.
Rating: 8/10
Comments: Another great map Roy!

name of map : route 1
fire red
please rate this its for the best team here on pc
map:

please rate

Suggestions: Try to fill up the space a bit better, Make the mountain more...Mountainish.
Rating: 6.5/10
Comments: Nice map, but far from perfect.

Here ya go guys, this is for Pokemon: Adventures in the Four Continents!
Rate & Review! Thanks!

Suggestions: Completely change it. Way to square, Way to symmetrical, Mountains are too square and straight, The map in general is too plain.
Rating: 1.5/10
Comments: I really don't like this map at all...

 

[Geeked]

Here's a new map with some new tiles :p

Map Name: Ridgepeak Mountain
Map Game: Fire Red:
Credits: Me mapping, Tb Pro & Zekku for tree & mountain tiles, X-Buster and Forgotten Memory for D/P Mart and Center.
Comments: I'm aware of the black spots you see on the "Tree-mountain" tiles, I'll fix them soon enough, please concentrate on the map :D (Took about 45 mins :p)
Map Shot:

 

[Golden Shaymin]

Here's a new map with some new tiles :p

Map Name: Ridgepeak Mountain
Map Game: Fire Red:
Credits: Me mapping, Tb Pro & Zekku for tree & mountain tiles, X-Buster and Forgotten Memory for D/P Mart and Center.
Comments: I'm aware of the black spots you see on the "Tree-mountain" tiles, I'll fix them soon enough, please concentrate on the map :D (Took about 45 mins :p)
Map Shot:

Map Rating: 7.5

Comments: I don't really like the cliffs on the left side of the second waterfall and I think the player needs 1 or 2 more places to rest in the grass areas

 

[Sandro™]

Map Name: None yet
Map Game: Fire Red
Credits: Tony for the rom base and TB Pro and Zeikku and all the rest for the tiles
Comments: I was bored i decided to make this map. Maybe i improved form the last time?
Map Shot:

 

[FoggyDoggy]

Name of Map : None

Hack Of: Fire Red Version

Comments: I thought I was making this for a hack, but I got another assignment, and I had to drasticly change this, but I diddnt want to lose it, so I saved it, and will use it when It is needed! ^-^

Mapshot:

Ratings Please, comments, and especially criticism, I want to become a better mapper, so I need to know what I do wrong, or badly.

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Map Name: None yet
Map Game: Fire Red
Credits: Tony for the rom base and TB Pro and Zeikku and all the rest for the tiles
Comments: I was bored i decided to make this map. Maybe i improved form the last time?
Map Shot:

It's a nice map only I think you should fill the big open places with soemthing cuz it's a little to open now... Rating 7-/10

Name of Map : None

Hack Of: Fire Red Version

Comments: I thought I was making this for a hack, but I got another assignment, and I had to drasticly change this, but I diddnt want to lose it, so I saved it, and will use it when It is needed! ^-^

Mapshot:


Ratings Please, comments, and especially criticism, I want to become a better mapper, so I need to know what I do wrong, or badly.

Alright.. Uuhm I'm a little annoyed with the huge amount of grass "-_- but it looks very nice the water and the rocks are very good but in the top and left of your map it's to blockish so you should try and make it more natural but it's a good map :) rating 8.1/10

 

[thethethethe]

I'm quite bored, so I decided to make like my first map in like two or three months
Map: I don't have a name
Rom: Fire Red

Spoiler:

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

I'm quite bored, so I decided to make like my first map in like two or three months
Map: I don't have a name
Rom: Fire Red

Spoiler:

Looks good only one little thing you should changethe rocks cuz it's to straight maybe some gaps ans so,,, but further it looks good, soo ratng 8.9/10

 

[Golden Shaymin]

Here's a new map i figured i'd test, please rate it

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Here's a new map i figured i'd test, please rate it

Looks nice, nicely filled the empty spots but you should make the trees more natural cuz it looks very blockish right now.. but still I like it i'll give it a 7.2/10

Ooh and btw you shouldn't use so many little trees in a row it isn't nice..;)

 

[destinedjagold]

I'm quite bored, so I decided to make like my first map in like two or three months
Map: I don't have a name
Rom: Fire Red

Spoiler:

RATINGS: 8/10
REASON: It's a very nice hidden town/city. Accessible only through surfing. It's really nice.
SUGGESTION: I think the white-colored fence is really useless, don't you think? Also, the signpost on the edge of the water is a bit annoying if we are surfing... Maybe giving it a few space from the water, perhaps?

Here's a new map i figured i'd test, please rate it

Spoiler:

RATINGS: 4/10
REASON: The map's unrealistic enough and it really looks square... :\
SUGGESTION: Fix the squareness of the map... :\

 

[Hiche..]

I'm quite bored, so I decided to make like my first map in like two or three months
Map: I don't have a name
Rom: Fire Red

Spoiler:

That's a great map.
I like the placement of the trees.
Rating: 8.7/10

 

[Binary]

I'm quite bored, so I decided to make like my first map in like two or three months
Map: I don't have a name
Rom: Fire Red

Spoiler:

Rating: 8.5/10
Reason: I like the map. Pretty good mapping after a long time. The trees are nicely placed and I like the use of the mountain tiles. Just one thing bothers me. You've used the same lab building thrice. Doesn't look that attractive. You need to have more variety.
Suggestions: Try to make the map more attractive. Try to add some more creativity.

Here's a new map i figured i'd test, please rate it

Rating: 6/10
Reason: The map is pretty squarish. Try to spread out the trees a little more. And there are many empty spaces you haven't used up. Using the same house looks boring doesn't it?
Suggestions: Just take note of the things I've said above.

 

[Platinum994]

Spoiler:

Rating: 8/10
Reason: good map thethethethe, but I don't like much the map with the original tiles...

 

[Disturbed]

Map Time :D

Name: Treesorrow Village
Credits: Alistair
Comments: You get surf here, so you can either go up or down river. Please do not judge by tiles. Unless you like them, then go right ahead and add that extra point that makes my day feel that 1% better. No seriously.

Spoiler:

This is my first map with these new tiles, so I really didn't have many good tiles for fillers :P

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

Map Time :D

Name: Treesorrow Village
Credits: Alistair
Comments: You get surf here, so you can either go up or down river. Please do not judge by tiles. Unless you like them, then go right ahead and add that extra point that makes my day feel that 1% better. No seriously.

Spoiler:

This is my first map with these new tiles, so I really didn't have many good tiles for fillers :P

I like this map. I like the tiles (they're awesome! I want!) Nice use of space and nice map overall! 8/10. The only concern is that when the mountain face goes into a corner that goes from facing right to facing backwards, it looks a bit weird. Sorry for bad description...