Map Rating/Review Thread

[loitraitim]

Map: Sandgem
Rom: Fired red
Commets: this is a rough of my sandgem i dont have the proper tiles right now but thats my temp

Oops!
Rating: 1/10
Very...very bugs... i dislike your map!
There are too many errors, you should be revised to think with maps!

 

[Surf]

okay before i get destroyed by comments saying the tiles are really overused, i made this map because its snowing outside xD and that i haven't seen many snow maps posted here lately

credit to Neti for the rom base

Brilliant Map i'll give it a 9.1 out of 10
because of the brilliant shape and the fact that i think i saw a tile error

 

[Hiche..]

Map: Sandgem
Rom: Fired red
Commets: this is a rough of my sandgem i dont have the proper tiles right now but thats my temp

It need much work, for there are a lot of tile errors. For example, the house is not completed, some trees are missing there end, the path has a lot of tile errors, the path also is very thick, and the Poke center is not done right.

Rating: 3/10

 

[Disturbed]

okay before i get destroyed by comments saying the tiles are really overused, i made this map because its snowing outside xD and that i haven't seen many snow maps posted here lately

credit to Neti for the rom base

I like the shape and everything...but there are around 40 tile errors I spotted. Yes, I am counting the bridges because you could easily avoid doing that. Also, there will be maybe 5 or 6 border problems throughout the map, and I don't really like the pathway going throughout the map.
4/10

 

[Heart's Soul]

okay before i get destroyed by comments saying the tiles are really overused, i made this map because its snowing outside xD and that i haven't seen many snow maps posted here lately

credit to Neti for the rom base

I am happy with snow tiles. However... I see many tile and border errors. Yes, the bridge needs some work on, but overall, it's a great map.
78.4/100

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Map name: Chen Si Seng [Legend Meditation]
Made on ROM: Fire Red
Made for hack: Pokémon Congbu
Comment: This is a map for my hack Pokémon Congbu, I haven't posted it here. But I wanted to show a preview of something of my hack so I thought I'd place this map ^^ Hope you like it and you will see more maps like this in my hack :)
Credits: Allistair & Kyledove for some tiles

 

[Neti]

Map name: Chen Si Seng [Legend Meditation]
Made on ROM: Fire Red
Made for hack: Pokémon Congbu
Comment: This is a map for my hack Pokémon Congbu, I haven't posted it here. But I wanted to show a preview of something of my hack so I thought I'd place this map ^^ Hope you like it and you will see more maps like this in my hack :)
Credits: Allistair & Kyledove for some tiles

This map is so damn great!
I dont rate maps often so iwont do it now cause there wont be a real comparison to other maps.
but i thought this would be a good thing to know for you^^
if it pops up in the next motw youll have my vote for sure, i dont think any comparible maps will appear on this thread within the next week, cause that doesnt happen very often

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

This map is so damn great!
I dont rate maps often so iwont do it now cause there wont be a real comparison to other maps.
but i thought this would be a good thing to know for you^^
if it pops up in the next motw youll have my vote for sure, i dont think any comparible maps will appear on this thread within the next week, cause that doesnt happen very often

Thanks ^^ I worked pretty hard on it :D
But there is only 1 thing I don't like myself of the map that is the pkmncenter and pkmnmart.. I will repost it maybe if I finished the mart [pokecenter already done ^^]

 

[Neti]

Thanks ^^ I worked pretty hard on it :D
But there is only 1 thing I don't like myself of the map that is the pkmncenter and pkmnmart.. I will repost it maybe if I finished the mart [pokecenter already done ^^]

you could also change the palette of the stairs, i think the shadow is too dark ;-)

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Map name: Chen Si Seng [Legend Meditation] [REVISION]
Made on ROM: Fire Red
Made for hack: Pokémon Congbu
Comment: This is a map for my hack Pokémon Congbu, I haven't posted it here. But I wanted to show a preview of something of my hack so I thought I'd place this map ^^ Hope you like it and you will see more maps like this in my hack :)
Credits: Allistair & Kyledove for some tiles

Changed the stair palette and Inserted the own made PC an PM ^^ [the roof is made by allistair or kyledove [don't know from who the house was -_-"]

 

[Heart's Soul]

Map name: Chen Si Seng [Legend Meditation] [REVISION]
Made on ROM: Fire Red
Made for hack: Pokémon Congbu
Comment: This is a map for my hack Pokémon Congbu, I haven't posted it here. But I wanted to show a preview of something of my hack so I thought I'd place this map ^^ Hope you like it and you will see more maps like this in my hack :)
Credits: Allistair & Kyledove for some tiles

Changed the stair palette and Inserted the own made PC an PM ^^ [the roof is made by allistair or kyledove [don't know from who the house was -_-"]

Nearly perfect! 98/100
This should be Map of the Year! Unless I see a better map

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Reposting my map :P
Please, rate and comment.. C+C is welcome

Alright, the border looks a bit blocky, also the mountain could be more natural..
The grass is pretty nice placed only you should try leaving a little tile open so it won't look to full, The logs annoy me abit, why do you use so much logs in 1 place.. further not really something to comment.. My rating: 7.1/10

 

[Disturbed]

Hi! I have another map... this one is directly from Distant. I never used these tiles before, so I need critisism.
Map Game: Firered/Distant

 

[+Sneasel™]

Hi! I have another map... this one is directly from Distant. I never used these tiles before, so I need critisism.
Map Game: Firered/Distant

Well, to start off, i don't like the path color ;) But that doesn't matter much...
Rating: 9/10
Reason: I think the path is way too big, maybe let the nice green grass through a bit...that's all ;) The trees are very nicely placed

 

[maoh4567]

Map name: Chen Si Seng [Legend Meditation] [REVISION]
Made on ROM: Fire Red
Made for hack: Pokémon Congbu
Comment: This is a map for my hack Pokémon Congbu, I haven't posted it here. But I wanted to show a preview of something of my hack so I thought I'd place this map ^^ Hope you like it and you will see more maps like this in my hack :)
Credits: Allistair & Kyledove for some tiles

Changed the stair palette and Inserted the own made PC an PM ^^ [the roof is made by allistair or kyledove [don't know from who the house was -_-"]

Wow! I really like this map!
I like your new PC and Mart, it matches perfectly to the map.
The vegetation are placed well!
There's one thing that made me this my favorite map.. its the series of mountains with a tree on top of it in the middle of the map.. why?.. because it reminds me of my special place ^^

I gave your map a 9.8/10 (This was the highest rating I gave)
2 things that I dont like in this map..
- The small mountain in the upper part.. its like an empty space filler
- The placement of paths

 

[Hiche..]

Hi! I have another map... this one is directly from Distant. I never used these tiles before, so I need critisism.
Map Game: Firered/Distant

A wonderful map indeed. The tiles are great. The path's color disturbs me a bit.
I like the placement of the trees, and houses. The palettes are good.

Rating: 8.5/10

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

please rate :/

 

[Hiche..]

please rate :/

A very well done map, TS. I like the shape of the sea, and how you placed the grass.
Rating: 8.7/10

 

[destinedjagold]

MAP NAME: LOW POINT PATH -Version 1-
MAP DESCRIPTION: A path which takes the player towards the icy parts of the Hevah Region.
MAP BASED ON: POKéMON Ruby U.S. Version (hacked for PKMN RD-LoG)
MAP SHOT: Click Me!!! or

Spoiler:

MAP COMMENT: This is the biggest map I have mapped in LoG so far... This is version 1 of LOW POINT PATH, so meaning I will edit this to improve it even more. Although I don't think I'll post version 2 of the map here though...

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

It got sorta shrinked, so it's hard to see...
What I can see though, is that the mountains look funny following the same path.
So...yah...6/10 of what I can see well...x.x