Naku's Big Bag of Mafia Shenanigans II

[Syndrome]

Maybe the hunter was roleblocked and killed simultaneously

That's all I have to suggest rn because I'm getting ready for class but maybe stuff will happen when I'm gone

 

[Charlie Brown]

You already outlined why that's a bad idea. The mafia will just lie leaving them with more information and us with misinformation, which is worse than none imo.

Okay thats true

 

[gimmepie]

Why not? I'm down. Harley Quinn. Two people fall in love with me but if they find out each other's identities they're pretty much fucked.

If I say who they are one of 'em will die though. But if someone gets a read on them (and one comes up as mafia or third party) I'll out them and hope the good one wins.

You probably just got someone killed if Harley Quinn works anything like the Seducers in my Blarz games that I assume she was based off of. Hopefully not and an actual identity is required.

 

[Ho-Oh]

The description said only if they find out who the other is. So as long as they keep quiet about being chosen (unless they seem scummy then I out them and hope for the best in the fight to the death) they're all good, I think.

 

[Arcaneum]

>let's all reveal our roles

Because that's going to work out well :thinking:

[Vote] no one

 

[Abby]

Voting nobody is boring

[VOTE]Ho-oh

 

[Ho-Oh]

Voting nobody is boring

[VOTE]Ho-oh

?_? Ummm why?

Although voting the person that just revealed their role (which one of the two people upon lynching of one of them can testify to - this is a silly sentence) kinda makes you seem scummy honestly.

 

[gimmepie]

?_? Ummm why?

Although voting the person that just revealed their role (which one of the two people upon lynching of one of them can testify to - this is a silly sentence) kinda makes you seem scummy honestly.

Revealing your role means nothing in a game where
a) It's super easy to lie about your role
b) Roles aren't always their standard alignment.

He's voting you because no-voting is often pushed by mafia members because it stifles investigation and helps preserve their numbers and can be easily swung to look towny. I assume he's pushing you to get a better read.

 

[jdthebud]

Yeah I think Valkyrie is likely with only one kill.

Bard, you can also add my Ninja SK suggestion to that list, which tbh seems more likely then an extremely lucky Surgeon kill. But who knows. Thankfully it seems we probably don't have a mafia aligned vig or other killing role like last time, which was awful.

I also agree that role revealing is not a good idea at this point.

 

[gimmepie]

Yeah I think Valkyrie is likely with only one kill.

Bard, you can also add my Ninja SK suggestion to that list, which tbh seems more likely then an extremely lucky Surgeon kill. But who knows. Thankfully it seems we probably don't have a mafia aligned vig or other killing role like last time, which was awful.

I also agree that role revealing is not a good idea at this point.

We can't call that at all. Valkyrie obscures how many killing roles there actually is.

 

[Abby]

For me there's never a use for wasting a d1 with everyone no killing - you'd roleclaimed after gp suggested not to so I parked a vote on you.

As for waiting for investagitave roles - There was multiple sanities suggested, waiting for them's gonna end up unproductive

 

[Syndrome]

I also suggested a role tailor made to kill cops, so if it was picked and they visit it it's gg.

 

[Arcaneum]

The madness continues, this is great, all mafia reasoning out the window with these roles around haha

 

[Pecilia]

I can't wait for the inevitable reset button.

Not-so-random-vote-whoever-was-the-last-poster-at-the-time-of-drafting-this-post Vote ##Vote Nick Wilde

 

[Sawsbuck]

It really sounds like it was a role that when visited causes death to the visitor, but we don't have anything like that and Hunter is a causes death after lynched role?

 

[gimmepie]

It really sounds like it was a role that when visited causes death to the visitor, but we don't have anything like that and Hunter is a causes death after lynched role?

Several scenarios for how this happened have been proposed. Any thoughts on those?

 

[Sawsbuck]

I'm not sure yet but I want to know what these roles are

Bus Driver
Ninja Serial Killer

 

[Bidoof FTW]

Harley Quinn is just a seducer with a twist.

But if we really have a Valkyrie would that stop the two deaths from taking place?

 

[gimmepie]

Harley Quinn is just a seducer with a twist.

But if we really have a Valkyrie would that stop the two deaths from taking place?

Fair point, it probably would.
Good.

 

[Midnight Umbreon]

Welp.

...
...
...
Yeah. that's right. I used a car picture. Anyway, nothing anyone has said so far makes sense. To me. rite now. I am tired. had a looping day. I'll try to vote someone later...