Pie Mafia [Endgame]

Joke vote?
Don't vote.
Maf gloats
At our votes
 
Aquacorde said:
does abby know something....
Click to expand...

If she does we'll likely have to decipher it, but honestly we could also just be being taunted.

Wiicked said:
Not sure I like that, it sounds like mafia paranoia to me.
Click to expand...

It's not like I've got much to work on. Doof's skepticism of everything is the only reason he seems even remotely trustworthy and even then he could easily be maf and trying to pull a fast one on Seth. What are your reads?
 
I find Twiggy's exasperated defense good enough not to vote for him (although admitting that he acts 'strange in every game' is giving me a bit of a cause for concern). I also assume that Abby has been cursed with something or other, and like the theory that American Pie is behind it. Honestly, this may seem like a random lynch, but when I was stalking this place for ages before posting, whenever Charlie Brown was near silent, things never ended well for the town. And he's only posted once so far, so...

[#VOTE] Charlie Brown
 
^ tbh a better question to ask is when am I never not quiet at the start of a game haha

[#VOTE] Lelouch I do feel like GP's singling out of Desi may have been softing tbh since it was quite random, and I feel that Twiggy's defence was genuine
 
Current Vote Count:

Twiggy - 7 (Johnny, TheCapsFan, Aquacorde, Bardothren, Nightkrow, gimmepie, Abby)
Lelouch - 3 (Wiicked, Salzorrah, Hau)
jdthebud - 1 (Altaria)
Wiicked - 1 (Lelouch)
Abby - 1 (Bidoof FTW)
Altaria - 1 (Nina)
Salzorrah - 1 (Seth Rollins)
Hau - 1 (Mr Cat Dog)

Voteless: Twiggy, Lucario

There are approximately 7 hours remaining in the phase.

Day 1 Vote Count #2
 
Hau said:
^ tbh a better question to ask is when am I never not quiet at the start of a game haha

[#VOTE] Lelouch I do feel like GP's singling out of Desi may have been softing tbh since it was quite random, and I feel that Twiggy's defence was genuine
Click to expand...

Just to save you some time, it wasn't.
 
gimmepie said:
You should be checked. I should be checked. Johnny should be checked. So on and so forth. Nobody is immune from suspicion and claiming you were trying to drum up conversation or establish reads or anything else of the like isn't going to save you from that.
Click to expand...

I don't get you. Are you scum reading me? If everyone should be checked why did you focus on me then?

Also I should be immune against weak suspicions right? I mean I can debunk them any day

It's not about drumming up conversations or establishing reads, those things don't really make you towny it's the motivation, the reactions and the personality that require reads, which is why I'm voting Gunner.

Label me as scum but I do not see Twiggy and scum and I'm not afraid to say it lol. Regardless if he flips mafia or town his bandwagon was one I found weak.
 
Seth Rollins said:
I don't get you. Are you scum reading me? If everyone should be checked why did you focus on me then?

Also I should be immune against weak suspicions right? I mean I can debunk them any day

It's not about drumming up conversations or establishing reads, those things don't really make you towny it's the motivation, the reactions and the personality that require reads, which is why I'm voting Gunner.

Label me as scum but I do not see Twiggy and scum and I'm not afraid to say it lol. Regardless if he flips mafia or town his bandwagon was one I found weak.
Click to expand...


I'm not scum reading you as such, but I do feel that you're more suspicious than most other players currently, bar Twiggy probably.
 
Seth Rollins said:
Can I ask why?
Click to expand...

You piled onto a joke vote, knowing it was a joke vote, and could have easily left your vote their and possibly would have if nobody had drawn attention to said vote. You then followed that up by targeting Gunner for acting exacting like she always does which doesn't make much sense to me at all. You're also defending Twiggy who has a perfectly valid - especially for Day One - bandwagon against him right now.

These points don't necessarily add up to you being scum and you could definitely still be innocent, but they do make you more suspicious than most of the other players in my eyes.
 
gimmepie said:
You piled onto a joke vote, knowing it was a joke vote, and could have easily left your vote their and possibly would have if nobody had drawn attention to said vote. You then followed that up by targeting Gunner for acting exacting like she always does which doesn't make much sense to me at all. You're also defending Twiggy who has a perfectly valid - especially for Day One - bandwagon against him right now.

These points don't necessarily add up to you being scum and you could definitely still be innocent, but they do make you more suspicious than most of the other players in my eyes.
Click to expand...

I could answer but I don't think this conversation is gonna take us anywhere. This is pretty much all I wanted to hear from you.

Don't dislike your response, so I guess you can fit in on my townreads :)
 
NIGHT 1


Jd rummaged through the pile left on the counter and took a closer look at the DVD and CD. "Well that's strange, why are they cracked? I don't remember it being that way before." He muttered to himself. "Well, guess whoever left them won't be wanting them anymore," he finished, pitching the ruined media into the trash.

Twiggy was lynched. He was:
Spoiler:
PM or Discord message me your night actions! You have 24 hours.
​
Rules and Mechanics
  1. Each day phase will last 48 hours. Each night phase will last 24 hours. These times are approximate.
  2. Lynch votes must be written in the format of [#VOTE] Username. If you want to change your vote, you must use the format [#UNVOTE] Username. Not following this format will result in your vote not being counted.
  3. Votes for a no lynch are NOT allowed, but a tied lynch vote will result in a no lynch.
  4. Missing two consecutive lynch votes will result in your removal from the game, or a sub filling your spot if possible.
  5. Do not share PMs for any reason. If you do, you will be modkilled.
  6. You can't target yourself.
  7. The GM, jdthebud, is a valid target for lynching or targeting at night. Perhaps something special will happen?!?
  8. All important game conversation should be kept in the game thread, or in any chats provided by the GM.
  9. If you are dead, don't haunt the thread, and refrain from liking any posts. You do get to post a single "death post" that may not contain any game-related information.
  10. Posting in the night phase is not allowed, unless stated otherwise.
  11. If you have any questions, feel free to ask jdthebud, either by PM or on Discord (jdthebud#2509).
The Pie List

jdthebud as Jd the Baker, the GM

Aquacorde
Hau
Bardothren
Lelouch
gimmepie
Salzorrah
Mr Cat Dog
Seth Rollins
Nightkrow
Bidoof FTW
Johnny
Abby
Lucario
Wiicked
Altaria
TheCapsFan
Nina

Empty Pie Tins (dead players)​

Lycanthropy as a Whipped Cream Pie (Vanilla Townie) - killed Night 0
Alex Kaz as Pecan Pie (Vigilante) - killed Night 0
Twiggy as American Pie (Watcher) - lynched Day 1

​
 
DAY 2


The math symbol acted again, this time with the utmost stealth. While yet another pie was forced to dream about infinite digits, his partner in pie crime slipped behind a different pie. The fungus rubbed its gills together in anticipation of the juicy treat that lay before it, then proceed to slurp it all down. "Mmm, I love the juice in this pie!" it thought. Then it encountered an unexpected object. "What is this pit doing in here? Wow, that baker really messed up!" It flung it away haphazardly, only to see it magically curve in midair and plop in a gooey pie only a couple racks away. "Well, that was interesting...wonder why it moved like that?"

Elsewhere, another seemingly unfortunate pie was confronted by a round face. "GIMME PIE!" It shouted. The pie cowered in fear for a moment, then realized it had nothing to fear, at least for this night. It gave no response and gave itself up. As the eager face began to chow down, it encountered a hard crust that was very tough to break through, and as it struggled with it, the intended victim was able to slide away to safety.

TheCapsFan was killed. He was:
Spoiler:
gimmepie has been revealed! He is the Cop.

Day 2 will last for 48 hours, and ends about 12:00AM PST on Tuesday, November 29.
​
Rules and Mechanics
  1. Each day phase will last 48 hours. Each night phase will last 24 hours. These times are approximate.
  2. Lynch votes must be written in the format of [#VOTE] Username. If you want to change your vote, you must use the format [#UNVOTE] Username. Not following this format will result in your vote not being counted.
  3. Votes for a no lynch are NOT allowed, but a tied lynch vote will result in a no lynch.
  4. Missing two consecutive lynch votes will result in your removal from the game, or a sub filling your spot if possible.
  5. Do not share PMs for any reason. If you do, you will be modkilled.
  6. You can't target yourself.
  7. The GM, jdthebud, is a valid target for lynching or targeting at night. Perhaps something special will happen?!?
  8. All important game conversation should be kept in the game thread, or in any chats provided by the GM.
  9. If you are dead, don't haunt the thread, and refrain from liking any posts. You do get to post a single "death post" that may not contain any game-related information.
  10. Posting in the night phase is not allowed, unless stated otherwise.
  11. If you have any questions, feel free to ask jdthebud, either by PM or on Discord (jdthebud#2509).
The Pie List

jdthebud as Jd the Baker, the GM

Aquacorde
Hau
Bardothren
Lelouch
gimmepie
Salzorrah
Mr Cat Dog
Seth Rollins
Nightkrow
Bidoof FTW
Johnny
Abby
Lucario
Wiicked
Altaria
Nina

Empty Pie Tins (dead players)​

Lycanthropy as a Whipped Cream Pie (Vanilla Townie) - killed Night 0
Alex Kaz as Pecan Pie (Vigilante) - killed Night 0
Twiggy as American Pie (Watcher) - lynched Day 1
TheCapsFan as Peach Pie (Oracle) - killed Night 1
​
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top