Rate a Shiny (revisted)

[Peter Tomlan]

I say 7.5 It's good, not wildly different but I like the fuchsia markings and bright green eye, I think they're just better colors than before, less drag and the brightness makes it seem more dangerous since things that can be poisonous like dart frogs could have a pattern like that.

Pretty cool despite not looking that much different than its normal variant. The colors actually resembles an Ultra Ball, hah. 7.7 out of 10 if I had to pick a rating for it.

 

[VisionofMilotic]

Drampa I'd give a 6.9 to. Not bad, I like gold shinies but to me the black eyebrows don't quite fit. I like black on shinies too but on pokemon that seem more fierce and serious like Charizard or Rayquaza. Drampa does have a temper, but still see it as a more whimsical pokemon.

Pretty cool despite not looking that much different than its normal variant. The colors actually resembles an Ultra Ball, hah. 7.7 out of 10 if I had to pick a rating for it.

Hi Peter welcome to the forum, glad you think shiny dragapault is kinda cool. Be sure to respond to the most recent post next time, and don't forget to leave us with a shiny pokemon to rate too :) Have a good weekend.

For the next shiny how about Lugia?

 

[Peter Tomlan]

Drampa I'd give a 6.9 to. I like gold shinies but to me the black eyebrows don't quite fit. I like black on shinies too but on the pokemon that seem more fierce and serious like Charizard or Rayquaza. Drampa does have a temper, but still see it as a more whimsical pokemon.


Hi Peter welcome to the forum, glad you think shiny dragapault is kinda cool. Be sure to respond to the most recent post next time, and don't forget to leave us with a shiny pokemon to rate too :) Have a good weekend.

For the next shiny how about Lugia?

Thank you for the welcome, and hello to you too! Sweet of you to give me a greeting here.

Good to let me know of the rules too. I'll keep that mind when posting in this thread.

As for the shiny Lugia, I like it a good deal. It's one of those shinies that's just good because of its opposite color swaps. Think Bishap and Gyarados. 7.9 out 10 for me. The shiny also makes me think it's more of a Psychic type.

What do we think of shiny Ho-oh? 🙂

 

[Devalue]

3.5/10. Looked at it a while. Objects to how much darker the reds feel. Sticks out too much, relative to the original.
__________

Diggersby?

 

[ReKoil]

5/10. Eh, not horrible, but I'm not big on shinies that just look like it got the life sucked out of the Pokemon.




Tapu Lele ?

 

[Devalue]

8/10. Generally likes black shinies, including this one. Might be too much black, though. Would have replaced the white sections with black instead of the pink sections.
_____________

Orbeetle?

 

[Alex_Among_Foxes]

7/10. Not bad, but a little too 'grape-y' looking to me.

Sandshrew?

 

[ReKoil]

8/10 - a shade of green that actually looks pretty good imo. Nice and distinct too.



Metagross? (gen 9 - gen 8)

 

[Devalue]

8.5/10. Cannot decide whether the original or shiny is better. Views either choice as good, regardless.
__________

Tarountula?

 

[ReKoil]

8/10 - Quite like it. A more unusual color combination in a shiny.

Nuzleaf ?

 

[Devalue]

5/10. Gave points for being bold. Does not like the orange/brown/green combination.
_____________

Carbink?

 

[LilyGardy]

6/10. It's a cute shiny.

Vaporeon

(It's purple)

 

[ReKoil]

8/10 - the best shiny eeveelution after Umbreon.

Espathra ?

 

[Alex_Among_Foxes]

While I'm not a big fan of the Pokemon itself, I do like the shiny colors. 8.5/10

Accelgor?

 

[Sheep]

I like the yellow but still a 6/10 for me, pretty meh regardless ):

Donphan?

 

[ReKoil]

7.5/10 - pretty solid, but nothing that wows.

Lycanroc ?

 

[Sheep]

9/10 I love the blue :'D



Galarian Stunfisk?

 

[ReKoil]

*goes 'wait, that's shiny?'*
*looks up orginal and shiny side by side on serebii*
Ah yeah...

5.5/10 - I guess. Difference is somewhat noticeable, but I haven't seen Galarian Stunfisk in quite a while apparently =P

Snubbull ?

 

[RadEmpoleon]

4/10 the colors themselves are fine, but they really don't work together.

Shiny Seedot?

 

[ReKoil]

6/10 - it's okay, but pretty much just a brighter brown.

Decidueye ?