I'd like that feature back. I found it pretty useful and well-balanced- like, people wanted a rematch often and it was easy to go find them and that. Although having a feature to call them up and request a battle instead of waiting for them to call you would be nice; just have a recharge time implemented on certain trainers/classes for that.
edit: also a way to sort the trainers so you can stick your frequent rematches at the top or whatever would be rad
This, basically. XD
The rematch feature was really great. If they brought it back, that would be awesome. Maybe a fusion with the Vs. Seeker? The HG/SS version did it quite well in my opinion, and since now we actually have a real 'real time clock' we could do that in OR/AS. I typically liked the way they did the Gym Leader rematches as well, 5 rematches that get progressively higher leveled. But just 1 strong rematch is good for me too.
A VS Seeker fusion could work. I'm not sure whether I would enjoy having to schedule a rematch for a specific time and day of the week; I typically just want to battle
now. XD A "Sinnoh Battleground/Fighting Dojo"-like facility where Gym Leaders gather would be nice, if we don't battle them in their own Gyms.
When arranging for rematches (mostly for Gym Leaders and any NPC Trainers who have enough Pokemon), the game should prompt the player with a menu containing the modes of Single Battle, Double Battle, Triple Battle, Rotation Battle, Sky Battle, and Inverse Battle. Any battle mode that can't be used for a particular Trainer (such as he/she having Pokemon that are ineligible for Sky Battles; he/she not having enough Pokemon for more than Single Battles, or he/she being involved in a forced Double Battle, like Senior & Junior Anna and Meg west of Mauville City) is disabled and cannot be selected.
If Steven Stone is in Meteor Falls like he was in
Emerald (although in OR/AS, after having been fought at EverGrande City), he should be rebattleable, complete with the "Battle! VS
Champion (Hoenn)" theme during his battle. (WTF rival battle theme? Seriously,
Emerald Version? No way, man!)
Also, those 2 girls in front of Shoal Cave should be battleable; it just irritated me that you can only battle them once!
Frontier Brains should be rematchable if you reach their point in another challenge (like if a Frontier Brain is normally the 35th and 70th Trainer fought, and they give you a Symbol once you beat them, if you have to restart your streak due to losing, the aformentioned Frontier Brain should be fought every time you get to the 35th/70th battle, complete with the "Battle! VS Frontier Brain (Hoenn)" music from
Pokemon Emerald :P).
Finally, it would be nice if Secret Base Trainers were rebattleable more than once per day...