• Our friends from the Johto Times are hosting a favorite Pokémon poll - and we'd love for you to participate! Click here for information on how to vote for your favorites!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

The Darkest Dungeon

faer said:
Ok, now I get what you mean. There is something pretty suss about this paragraph, BUT the corpse it's talking about is Spectrums:

It's pretty suss, that of all people you were to find the body after the Prophet did what it did, but it might as well be only some narrative?
I absolutly don't see any connection to jdthebud, except if you wanna frame him as being the Prophet himself. Which is ...pretty farfetched imho.
Click to expand...

I thought that too at first, but it seems strange that I'd be the only role ever mentioned solely for the sake of narrative purposes. So far it seems that every time a role has been mentioned it's been for a reason.

The reason this makes me think of JD is because I voted for him last day phase and was the first to do so. Otherwise there's nothing that could connect me to someone and I doubt I was used just because "why not?"
 
Thanks for coming to my defense guys, I now have a chance to repond to this GP's suspicion.
faer said:
Hey JD, just wondering, after you got attacked by three people yesterday, did you get attacked at night as well?
Click to expand...
It seems I was attacked and healed last night. I don't know what the values were but it added up to 0 damage.
gimmepie said:
We only get one attack during the day, I attacked JD. I admit that this isn't the strongest of cases, however there's something suss here because jd isn't dead. He's taken a lot of damage but he's very much so still alive (indicating a power role). Since he was described as a corpse though, it stands to reason that the Necromancer might have something to do with him... although it should be noted it looks like he was targeted by this prophet character.
Click to expand...
I have a Hero role, but my health is not all that good, I've taken a total of 30 damage so far and will die very soon unless I'm healed. Zehn, any chance you could do so? Being able to take damage is NOT suspicious in and of itself, as most of the Heroes have pretty strong HP, and my role has a useful ability, albeit limited in that I can only use it twice.
gimmepie said:
I thought that too at first, but it seems strange that I'd be the only role ever mentioned solely for the sake of narrative purposes. So far it seems that every time a role has been mentioned it's been for a reason.

The reason this makes me think of JD is because I voted for him last day phase and was the first to do so. Otherwise there's nothing that could connect me to someone and I doubt I was used just because "why not?"
Click to expand...
While I agree that you finding a corpse could be interesting information, first, I am not dead, so the corpse is not me. Also, I did not kill anyone yesterday, the person I attacked yesterday is still alive, so no corpses from yesterday are connected to me?

As far as who else could be suspicious, there was this post by wizardman11 last page:
Wizardman11 said:
I also have reason to believe marz is one of these four roles, although I made some assumptions about eliminating some from the list: Bloodletter, Cutthroat, Shambler, or Blacksmith. It's a 75% chance that, assuming this is correct, he is a monster. If anyone has any information that can help with this, like if they also attacked marz and what their attack value is, that would be appreciated.
Click to expand...
Also, Lycanthropy seems a little suspicious since they attacked Lawlietta, who was confirmed a villager on D1, although it's possible he could have taken an "evil" villager role? But Lycanthropy seemed to think he was a Swine, which is interesting. I doubt he would attack so early in the day phase if he wasn't sure about it, even if he is going to be gone for the rest of the weekend. We might not be able to get another reply from him before the end of the day phase though -_-
 
Mana said:
There were 9 villagers and 9 new roles iirc. Lawli's defense against Wizard seems pretty suss too, since she's not accusing him of lying but assuming his role is manipulated.

Eh.

[attack] Lawlietta
Click to expand...

How can you be sure of your analysis when you don't even check who made the claim? (fyi it was Lycan). Clearly you're very willing to jump to conclusions, which is something I tried to avoid by not accusing Lycan.
Also to answer to machomuu's point about the role thing, my point is that Klippy did not give me a role. I have no role, so I'm really not sure about the calculations, but again, it is entirely possible that people with roles have died. Just because I don't have a role doesn't make me suspicious. In my opinion, Lycan's claim is more so because he hasn't even told us how he got his information. I guess I see your point of view with me being an obvious target to vote for as (I've already been accused) and not thinking carefully about the source and validity of the information given, but I don't think this justifies rash decisions. If you want to kill me, fine, I'm not very useful, but you'll be losing one more person from your side so it's your loss.

Also Zehn, you should probably Ullion or Wizard, since they have roles and very little health. Maybe Wizard because he says his role is important tonight?
 
I wasn't listening to Lycan, actually. There was a post much earlier (when Zehn was under scrutiny) confirming the number of villagers and it matched the number of names. No 'villager' has been mentioned since, and it was heavily implied all have new names/roles.

Sooo that's what I based my vote on.
 
jdthebud said:
As far as who else could be suspicious, there was this post by wizardman11 last page:
Click to expand...
Why am I sus for providing information? I literally tell you guys all the information I have about people bc I'm probably going to die soon and people jump at me because of it.
Lawlietta said:
Also Zehn, you should probably Ullion or Wizard, since they have roles and very little health. Maybe Wizard because he says his role is important tonight?
Click to expand...
I don't think 5 health would make that much of a difference, and even with it I could be easily killed. But then again it could mean the difference between life and death, and tonight that could be detrimental to the innos if I die before my action goes through.
 
Omg Wiz please

He was referencing your list, not you. Get with the program.
 
Lawlietta said:
In my opinion, Lycan's claim is more so because he hasn't even told us how he got his information. I guess I see your point of view with me being an obvious target to vote for as (I've already been accused) and not thinking carefully about the source and validity of the information given, but I don't think this justifies rash decisions. If you want to kill me, fine, I'm not very useful, but you'll be losing one more person from your side so it's your loss
Click to expand...
It's really not about about trusting Lycanthropy or not- honestly, when he said that bit about you I merely thought it was a tidbit to keep in mind. However, my real problem is that you claim that you're a villager despite that not having been possible.

But if that's really the case, there's a simple solution: contact Klippy. Just ask him what your role is, simple as that. If you're telling the truth, Zehn should be able to heal you right up.
 
gimmepie said:
So do I vote for JD, Wizard or Lawli?

They seem the best options to me atm.
Click to expand...
Continuing on from what Wizard just said, Lawli's health is pretty low so that'd be a waste, too; pretty much the same scenario. Personally, for me, the jury's still out on JD, but you seem to already have come to a conclusion (and a while ago, for that matter).
 
Personally I don't feel that Gimme needs to attack someone new, that's just causing excess damage to potential innocents. He would be better off finishing someone who's close to death and doing less damage overall.

Unless we get a confirmed target, then by all means~

Or heal Grey Bidoof.
 
Oh yeah, Bidoof would be a good one. From a practical standpoint, Bidoof's the best choice (nooooot a sentence I plan repeating any time soon).

I'd imagine he has marginally more health than Ullion, but he's also been outed as a pretty important role.

faer said:
Um, may I vote for Bacteriophage? He's not so low on health, so it wouldn't be a waste.
Click to expand...
Quoting, since it got stuck at the bottom of the last page.
 
Cheshire Cat said:
I thought I could trust you!
Click to expand...
Oh damn, he just played the trust card.

[PokeCommunity.com] The Darkest Dungeon
 
Well after reading through this mess I have to say that if both Lawli and JD are low on health AND suspicious, then why don't we just gang up and attack them? Grey Doof needs the health obviously so please heal him. He is an important role and is confirmed. I'm still not sure I believe that Foxrally is a just a normal revived guy because the Necromancer had something to do with it. Not to mention that the Necromancer has an Acolyte mentioned like directly below it so yeah. This is even more concerning when you take into consideration that he was the only one revived after being mouth-tickled by senpai death like what even.
 
Didn't lawli claim she was low on health? If this is true then if enough of us attack her then you could probably smash Foxrally again.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top