4th Gen A G/S Remake?

[MiTjA]

oh yes, i noticed in a video that on platinum, you get a togepi egg, just like in G/S/C.
Maybe another sign that there may be a G/S remake?

That's rather a thing in Platinum that is the same as in GSC which would make the chances for a remake lower in some way, if you ask me =(

 

[Precious Tears]

oh yes, i noticed in a video that on platinum, you get a togepi egg, just like in G/S/C.
Maybe another sign that there may be a G/S remake?

Yes, I was wondering that too... Cynthia could give the player another egg... But why would she give Togepi, instead of Elekid or Magby?

 

[Luck]

Yes, I was wondering that too... Cynthia could give the player another egg... But why would she give Togepi, instead of Elekid or Magby?

because like before, you get a togepi egg, although mitja is right.
It would make the chance of a remake possibly lower because there will be even less of a point in a remake.
its pretty easy enough to get all johto pokemon, so maybe they made it easier.

 

[Precious Tears]

because like before, you get a togepi egg, although mitja is right.
It would make the chance of a remake possibly lower because there will be even less of a point in a remake.
its pretty easy enough to get all johto pokemon, so maybe they made it easier.

Nintendo is toying us, our mind...

 

[Buoysel]

Nintendo is toying us, our mind...

Why must they toy with us? I will pay to play.

 

[Barney.]

A G/S/C remake would be so sweet!

Lugia and ho-oh! - They'd be so good...Seeing ans Lugia is impossible to purify on XD and Ho-oh's hard to get on Colleseum.

So yeah im a full supporter of this idea :P

 

[TheReignOverhead]

Would be nice, but it's not gonna happen. I guarantee it.

 

[Dunsparce]

Would be nice, but it's not gonna happen. I guarantee it.

Johto is a location in the coding and Raikou/Entei/Suicune are nowhere to be found in Platinum. That's enough evidence for me.

 

[Luck]

Would be nice, but it's not gonna happen. I guarantee it.

You can't guarantee something that wasn't announced.
its about as guaranteeing as telling people that mew is a shaved cat.

Johto is a location in the coding and Raikou/Entei/Suicune are nowhere to be found in Platinum. That's enough evidence for me.

but you can migrate pokemon from FR/LG.
if the three beasts weren't in FR, then a G/S remake would've been big, because the only other place to find them is in coliseum, where its impossible if you don't have a GC.
and then the johto data, it may be just something that Nintendo planned to do, but canceled.
the johto data means nothing, unless you count increasing a rumour.
except for celebi, every pokemon in johto can be caught.
i'll even make a list if no one believes me.
but i did find it weird that they put the bird and regi trio in, but not the beasts.

 

[.Missingno]

i have heard that nintendo ha copy righted the names dawn gold and dusk silver could this mean something?????

 

[bobandbill]

Would be nice, but it's not gonna happen. I guarantee it.

Please provide evidence for that guarantee then. -_-

but you can migrate pokemon from FR/LG.
if the three beasts weren't in FR, then a G/S remake would've been big, because the only other place to find them is in coliseum, where its impossible if you don't have a GC.

Well, actually, one one of the beasts are in FR/LG, leastways one per game file. Not to mention that they are roaming Pokemon, and if they use Roar they cannot be encountered again. On the other hand, Colosseum can be played on the Wii...

The main point is that these Pokemon are not available in 4th gen games. Various 1st and 3rd gen legendaries are so far obtainable in Platinum, indicating perhapes Nintendo want them for the most part to be obtainable for those who haven't/won't play the third gen games (GBA games are getting obsolute) - but the Johto beasts aren't available in a 4th gen game yet. A notable absence - but why?

and then the johto data, it may be just something that Nintendo planned to do, but canceled.
the johto data means nothing, unless you count increasing a rumour.

True - it could count for nothing, but I doubt it. Taking Colo and XD Pokemon as an example - they say they are obtainable 'From a Distant Land' - not from Orre, which strikes me as odd. They probably hadn't programmed in anything saying Orre for RS and all, so just went with that anyway. Yet, in Diamond and Pearl, amognost all the other regions (including the reuse of 'Distant Land'), were two spots labeled 'Johto'. I've seen the coding for myself first hand. But why do it? It shows that, at the very least. they were considering making a remake, and the continued 'evidence' for this possibilty merely underlines it. Sure, it might not happen, as I've said eariler, but it certainly does mean something IMO.

except for celebi, every pokemon in johto can be caught.
i'll even make a list if no one believes me.

Ah, but not every Pokemon from Johto is obtainable in 4th gen game. Kanto legendary birds got in despite being availalbe in XD and FR/LG, unlike the Johto beasts in which all three availble in Colo, and one of them in FR/LG in 'harder' circumstances'. The Regis too are available thus far. But not one of the Johto legendaries - the beasts or Lugia/Ho-oh - are in a 4th gen game yet. Some other non-legendary Johto Pokemon too aren't readily available in 4th gen games just yet.

Meh, I'm feeling objective today. 'Cause', it isn't going to happen or not happen for sure, but IMO all these things point towards a remake happening rather then not.

As for the Togepi thing - who's to say you wouldn't get a different Pokemon in the remake? 'Cause, that's if they don't copy everything that GSC was like to a T...
Edit:

i have heard that nintendo ha copy righted the names dawn gold and dusk silver could this mean something?????

Nope. Platinum, for instance, hadn't been copyrighted or the such (in fact the website domain for Poke. Platinum I believe already was taken by a fans forum or something?), but Opal had. And many people thought that the neame couldn't possibly be Platinum, but be Opal. Goes to show it doesn't actually count for anything. In fact if you look around you can find some fake boxart for those games already - emphasis on the fact that it's fake.

 

[Skip Shot]

Can't you trade Lugia and Ho-oh from XD/Colosseum to FR/LG/Emerald after geting the Natl. Dex and then transfer to D/P/Pt?

(This is kinda not s'posed to be here, but how close r u to ch. 12 in ur fanfic?)

 

[bobandbill]

Can't you trade Lugia and Ho-oh from XD/Colosseum to FR/LG/Emerald after geting the Natl. Dex and then transfer to D/P/Pt?

Yes... what I mean is you can't get them straight from 4th gen games without having to have any 3rd gen games. Unlike Regis and Kanto birds you can't get Johto legendaries from 4th gen games.

(oh, and check your visitor messages in a moment, hardcorerock ;) )

 

[Ripper]

What makes me think is to whether there is data saying that the Pokemon was traded from another region, not Pal Parked. For instance, what would that game say if a Pokemon was traded? We don't know whether the dat only works for Pokemon transferred from Johto and as we can be sure, qa remake won't be for the GBA, but the DS.

 

[Buoysel]

What makes me think is to whether there is data saying that the Pokemon was traded from another region, not Pal Parked. For instance, what would that game say if a Pokemon was traded? We don't know whether the dat only works for Pokemon transferred from Johto and as we can be sure, qa remake won't be for the GBA, but the DS.

Not trying to be mean, but you should proof read your posts. I can barely understand it.

You have a valid point, but you don't express it right. I don't know what to say about that, I though about that, but I just wanted to show the pics I had found to somebody.

 

[Volkner's Apprentice]

Honestly, I just hope and pray this is the next installment. A new region might be a little much, but returning all the great features of G/S/C like the Bug Catching Contest, Pokemon found day/night/morning, days of the week, special weekly/monthly/daily events, maybe even introduce a batch of new Pokemon, a mixup with the gym leaders/E4 and add some fun extras like seasons or tournaments you can enter.

[/drooling]

 

[The Abyss]

What makes me think is to whether there is data saying that the Pokemon was traded from another region, not Pal Parked. For instance, what would that game say if a Pokemon was traded? We don't know whether the dat only works for Pokemon transferred from Johto and as we can be sure, qa remake won't be for the GBA, but the DS.

That would be alright except that there aren't any games that have Johto that can be traded with D/P

 

[Rich Boy Rob]

What makes me think is to whether there is data saying that the Pokemon was traded from another region, not Pal Parked. For instance, what would that game say if a Pokemon was traded? We don't know whether the dat only works for Pokemon transferred from Johto and as we can be sure, qa remake won't be for the GBA, but the DS.

Why would it be for GBA anyway? They aren't even produced anymore are they?

 

[Precious Tears]

What makes me think is to whether there is data saying that the Pokemon was traded from another region, not Pal Parked. For instance, what would that game say if a Pokemon was traded? We don't know whether the dat only works for Pokemon transferred from Johto and as we can be sure, qa remake won't be for the GBA, but the DS.

Hacked Chikorita, showing DM/PL has the data of Johto in game.

Shellos's sprite is pink, like its west sea variation, and seems to combine the western variation's head with the eastern variation's body, while Gastrodon's sprite is brown and looks like its western variation, but with more rock-like protrusions on its body. This may also be another "unofficial confirmation" of Pokémon Gold and Silver remakes since its Pokédex data states that its colors and shapes differs from region to region, although it is unlikely, considering the similarities to the existing forms, and the fact that there are no front sprites for either of the beta forms.

Unused Shellos and unused Gastrodon sprite.

What do you say guys?

 

[.Nighthawk.]

you can tell easily that is fake !