Yeah, same here, I could probably do both, but the moment I pay attention to what I'm doing...nope, there goes all sense of rhythm.
Yeah, they made us learn recorders back in elementary school, but only for the 4th/5th graders. 3rd grade me was so envious of the older kids being able to play it, especially since I'd happened to get one as a Christmas present not too long before. However, that instrument is now forever ruined in my mind because all I'll be able to think about is a classroom of kids with squeaky, plastic recorders. My ears hurt just even thinking about it.