Grandmafia [IT'S OVER]

jdthebud said:
I still think the Bingo Card thing doesn't add up, so [Execute] Golgari. Not that it matters, this is probably more of a fos vote then anything else.
Click to expand...

Think it's a good idea to try to nail Golgari next? I'm curious about your opinion (and everyone else's.)

Klippy must go, though.
 
I have a bad feeling that we're getting played, but I can't tell if it's that the bingo card was lying to Golgari, or that Golgari is lying about the card to begin with... But I feel like that would be a terrible play on Golgari's part cause the fos would be on him the next day, soo I guess [Execute] Klippy
 
I only regret that I had but two lives to give.
 
Good morning elders, children, and bingo players.

It appears that the only third party roles left are the bingo caller and nanny, we also know for sure that there are at least two more children - the thief and moody teenager were both mentioned, and we don't have a confirmed number of bingo players, but I'm going to guess they have somewhere around 3-4 members. It also appears that the bingo card I received was correct about Klippy.

So, how should we proceed?
 
uh guys, the cat's dead :(

So here are the people left

Wizardman11
Davepetasprite^2
PrincePuffin
Golgari
Juno
Superjolt
Twiggy
jdthebud
kid
Bardothren

2 people are probably Whippersnappers, 2 third party (nanny, and bingo caller), and the bingo goers, and the innos left.

We could say that nanny is probably a werewolf role, because they drained a whippersnappers life?

If at most we have 4 or more potential candidates. Juno and I have softclaimed, but most probably the bingo caller has gotten us so that is not so much reliable. But it does prove that we are not whippersnappers or the nanny, or the bingo caller. jd probably softclaimed but idr if he did.

tbh, im fosing on bard and twiggy tho... maybe even superjolt :x idk why but i feel bard could probably be the bingo caller coz he's been a recruiter for how many times now, and i cant shake the feeling that he's one as well. however thats just my gunner gut talking and you guys know how "reliable" it is so take that with a grain of salt >.>
 
anyone know how many of the bingo caller recruits were killed? it's d6 but i know there aren't 7 recruits among us or they would've won by now.

edit: 7 including the bingocaller himself
 
Hi yes I'll cast the first vote

Execute Twiggy

Pretty obvious read, Twiggy is pretty scummy
 
[PokeCommunity.com] Grandmafia [IT'S OVER]


"To be, or not to be--that is the question:
Whether 'tis nobler in the mind to suffer
The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune
Or to take arms against a sea of troubles
And by opposing end them. To die, to sleep--
No more--and by a sleep to say we end
The heartache, and the thousand natural shocks
That flesh is heir to."

My cat, tis dead, lay in a terrible state.
This ache, my head, it hurts of late.
I ponder my grief as my cat lies dead,
While slowly, I pat his head.
My grief, it drowns me in a sea of hate.
While I, inevitably ponder my fate.
​
 
im not gonna lie, doof doesnt seem to be scummy to me tbh. why would a cultist sacrifice themselves just to get a whippersnapper killed? tbh if doof does come out as a cultist, im just gonna clap at that coz babe thats risky as ****.
 
Ok, if my calculations are right, the Bingo Cult can't have 4 recruits right now because that would put the Cult count at 5 (Caller + 4 recruits) and they would have won today since there's 10 players left now. So the cult has at least 3 recruits assuming the Caller didn't fail in any of the early night phases. We're in a dangerous situation because the cult could be in a winning position if we mess up the lynch today - so we either need to lynch a recruit or the Caller himself.

Now here's the interesting thing - none of the confirmed innos that died from inactivity flipped as third party (Zehn, Fox, and Rozu were confirmed by the Wise Old Man's lists) so they were not recruited. I'm pretty sure Gunner and Juno have been recruited. They are the only other players confirmed inno by the lists and the rest didn't flip third party. The Caller would have been pretty foolish not to snatch up any of the confirmed innos (or it would be an incredibly risky move to try recruiting anyone else, at least). So I'm kind of hesitant to trust what they say right now

Not enough time to finish the rest of my thoughts, I'll continue later
 
Davepetasprite^2 said:
Now why would the caller try to recruit me when theres a huge risk of him getting killed?
Click to expand...
Hmm... a fair point, but you do only get to go on watch 3 times. You could have used up your 3 uses or simply not have gone on watch one night. It just doesn't make much sense for the Caller to not have recruited any of the confirmed innos, and like I said, the other confirmed innos didn't flip as third party.

And Juno, idk, maybe you still keep your chat with the Cat Lady even after being recruited? It's like I said above, only in Gunner's case, she has a role that could have deterred the Caller, however in your case there's really nothing to stop the Caller. So I guess if Gunner wasn't recruited, there's a really high chance that you were.

In the case of Twiggy, I'm still kind of doubtful. If he is in the cult, then Nimsy was really bussing him hard on D4. Twiggy could be the Caller himself, but I don't think Nimsy would risk getting the cult leader lynched. Even if he was just a recruit, I think it would still be risky to lose even a single recruit when you're trying to outnumber everyone else.

So with confirmed players/players that have claimed (and if jd is what I think he is) then we're left with these players for possible Bingo Caller:

PrincePuffin
Golgari
Kid
Bardothren
Twiggy (but only if it's not one of these 4 above)

Gonna rule out Bard because I don't think he could be the Caller, especially after what he said about being FathR in Blarz 2, I think I believe him. It could be PrincePuffin, since he's a new player, I could see him being unsure as the Caller and missing the fact that he could have just recruited among the confirmed innos. It could be Kid, who has slipped by and contributed next to nothing the whole game. But then it could be Golgari too. I know what I said before about thinking he's town, but after all those flips, something feels off here. I agree with Gunner about it being risky for him to claim he's received a message and sacrifice himself, but... I can't help but think it's just a WIFOM situation where Golgari lied about all of it and just hoped we would think it was too risky.

Going with [Execute] Golgari for now. Gonna think this over a little more and see what everyone else thinks as well, might end up changing this later
 
I have a bit of time left before I need to cast my vote, so... Golgari where'd you get that bingo card from?
 
I got it in the middle of the last day phase.

I don't know why I received it, considering that I haven't gotten another or anything similar... It confuses me as well, but I decided to trust it and it was right. Can't say I'd want to trust it again if I got another, considering that we need to find the bingoers and stop them ASAP
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top