Grandmafia [IT'S OVER]

ಠ__ಠ

If we're going by avatars, jd's avatar doesn't even have teeth.
 
Hmm, didn't really consider the Bingo Caller to be the one that killed Mr. Rogers when he tried to recruit them because I didn't think cannibal Bingo Caller made much sense (and it did sound more like it was the Alien instead) but the clue about the plastic coin being dropped was weird. And then it got me thinking - what if it wasn't the Bingo Caller himself but one of his recruits?

Mana said it can't be an 'old man' because they wouldn't have many teeth (though I'm not sure if I really agree with that). But let's say this does apply. Perhaps the "toothy man" then simply refers to one of the 'younger' roles like the Youthful Elder (who looks incredibly young and most certainly would have all his teeth), or even the Salesman? Maybe one of them has been recruited and Ash targeted them?
 
I'm pretty sure Ash tried to recruit a third party because she's dead. Mr. Rogers recruiting third party = dead Mr. Rogers. So really we must be looking at the alien, bingo caller or a bingo cultist, and I still stand by my previous comment - normal humans don't typically chew off other peoples' arms.

I still don't get how this "which role killed Ash" discussion helps us figure out what to do next though, unless someone knows the players of these roles.
 
I would like to question the same thing, honestly...

I can't believe that all I said was how I don't get who the narrative was trying to talk about stemmed into such a discussion about this ordeal. That post was like, idk, your "daily-shitpost-during-the-beginning-of-a-phase-on-the-early-stages-of-the-game" type of post.

Well unless one of you happened to be stalking Ash last night. Is there a role that does that?
 
Ok, hi guys. I'm catching up on everything that has happened. I'll post when I do so.
 
Yeah, agreed with Bard about the avatars, and agreed with Juno that this discussion isn't really getting us anywhere.

So maybe the list that Johnny got really is our best bet for now?

EDIT: Also will the Wise Old Man be giving out another list? It does say he "spreads his knowledge daily"
 
Superjolt said:
Yeah, agreed with Bard about the avatars, and agreed with Juno that this discussion isn't really getting us anywhere.

So maybe the list that Johnny got really is our best bet for now?

EDIT: Also will the Wise Old Man be giving out another list? It does say he "spreads his knowledge daily"
Click to expand...

I agree with Superjolt agreeing with Bard about the avatars, and also agree with Superjolt about agreeing with Juno about this discussion not being helpful.

Who do we pick from Johnny's list though?
 
Superjolt said:
So maybe the list that Johnny got really is our best bet for now?

EDIT: Also will the Wise Old Man be giving out another list? It does say he "spreads his knowledge daily"
Click to expand...
I was also wondering about the wise man, someone else should have gotten a list, if they aren't sharing then they could be suspicious, whoever the Wise Old Man is should keep that in mind.

As for that "savagery", as Bard put it, that did come out of nowhere, I thought this was a peaceful senior community! And no, I did not eat Mr. Rogers.
 
Nimsy said:
I'm pretty sure wolves have teeth.
Click to expand...

Yeah but gnawed. That's a beaver/bidoof, or perhaps a rat. A wolf isn't going to gnaw.

I'll be voting once I'm back from work, we need to get the ball rolling, but I think our two main suspects are Golgari and Juno. Doof for the obvious clues going in and Juno for being on the list (and I find her somewhat suspicious).
 
[Kill]Davepetasprite^2
 
Hmmm... Zehn?
[PokeCommunity.com] Grandmafia [IT'S OVER]


I understand that you may want to go off Johnny's list, but I'm questioning that action over there.
 
Mana said:
Yeah but gnawed. That's a beaver/bidoof, or perhaps a rat. A wolf isn't going to gnaw.

I'll be voting once I'm back from work, we need to get the ball rolling, but I think our two main suspects are Golgari and Juno. Doof for the obvious clues going in and Juno for being on the list (and I find her somewhat suspicious).
Click to expand...

Wolves gnaw on sticks and bones, so why not a hand?
Also gnaw in this case may just mean "bite".

Since gnaw means to bite at or nibble something persistently, and his hand was eaten pretty fast. I don't think that one could gnaw that quickly.
 
I'm VERY uncomfortable with linking Golgari/Bidoof to the one that killed Mr.Roger. I would consider giving such meta-game hints bad style. Especially with how Golgari himself made the first post mentioning the bidoof. Either he wants to get himself killed to get more time for his own game which is finally up or someone is traing hard to frame him.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top