Bidoof FTW
[cd=font-family:carter one; font-size:13pt; color:
- 3,547
- Posts
- 10
- Years
- the States
- Seen Apr 5, 2024
Since Johnny is talking mad trash in Skype but won't actually bring it in the thread where it belongs I'll address his thoughts here.
First of all, that wasn't the point at all. You're nitpicking and/or not trying to figure out what I'm saying. I'm saying that throwing around suspicion to try and get a lynch going doesn't make someone suss. We're going to have to mislynch eventually, and day one mislynching is not the end of the world. We can come back from it, and get it right.
Also, the fact that Nimsy will be brave enough to throw around suspicion even as an innocent supports the idea that if Nimsy does it again, she won't automatically be mafia. She's done it as inno, so if she does it again why would she be mafia? If anything, calling someone out for: being quick to lynch, refusing to join a bandwagon, or wanting to point suss at someone in order to get more information is even more illogical than how you made my post look by using a fallacy.
So if I get this right, figuring out two of the dead people's roles before anyone else, and trying to show you why you're wrong/making a mistake is pointless posting.
Compared to someone trying to get someone else to reveal on day one because they visited a loudmouth, when the loudmouth lived.
Golgari said:It's starting again. AND LAST TIME SHE WAS RIGHT!
JonathanMustang said:And this you call logic
Do not bandwagon her because last time she was right.
First of all, that wasn't the point at all. You're nitpicking and/or not trying to figure out what I'm saying. I'm saying that throwing around suspicion to try and get a lynch going doesn't make someone suss. We're going to have to mislynch eventually, and day one mislynching is not the end of the world. We can come back from it, and get it right.
Also, the fact that Nimsy will be brave enough to throw around suspicion even as an innocent supports the idea that if Nimsy does it again, she won't automatically be mafia. She's done it as inno, so if she does it again why would she be mafia? If anything, calling someone out for: being quick to lynch, refusing to join a bandwagon, or wanting to point suss at someone in order to get more information is even more illogical than how you made my post look by using a fallacy.
JonathanMustang said:I have nothing to say to that pointless posts you're doing.
So if I get this right, figuring out two of the dead people's roles before anyone else, and trying to show you why you're wrong/making a mistake is pointless posting.
Compared to someone trying to get someone else to reveal on day one because they visited a loudmouth, when the loudmouth lived.