Thanks Fletch. You saved us the trouble.
I disagree with the suspicion on Sawsbuck. It was too risky a play for scum to try imo, but he may have been trying to bait me, thinking I'd show my hand, or something.
So, looking at the game right now, both Dark Angels are in play, as well as Dark Dreamer and Magic Man, along with three vanilla town, the Priest, the Tinker, a Slasher due to die soon, and the President. The Mafia gets two Night Kills thanks to the Magic Man, and getting that Slasher ability gives them one more. In addition, the Dark Angels can recruit two people at any time and have yet to do so, and they can do so freely now that the Faithful is gone.
I'd say, unless we get lucky today, we're up against a cult of four and a mafia of two with five town. Dark Dreamer can't die until the Magic Man falls, but the bigger concern is the Dark Angels. If nothing is done, they could win tomorrow, while the soonest mafia can win would be two days from now. The question is, should we let Fletch explode and hope for the best, or dispose of him ourselves and/or hope someone else does it for us?
Looking back at the dawn post, it looks like Priest got hit last night, by one of the mafia kills. It'd be wise for them to out, since I can't imagine the mafia letting them live another day.
I personally don't think Saws is scum or cult, since that play was too risky. EC has been... interesting. Perhaps he's the Serial Killer? At this point, I could imagine SK being a fool role, trying to get lynched, or something like that. His behavior just screams fool. jd's been on the quieter side for most of the game, and something tells me he came out of the woodwork to bus gimmepie. That's the only thing that sticks out to me as far as behavior goes.
EDIT: I took a look back at gimmepie's statements. Looks like the townreads he commonly gave were Kiyo, Naku, Fletch, and Sparkin, along with Newtsie and EC. He scumread doof on D1. He pointed out that L'Belle and jd were quiet, but said that it didn't mean they were scum. Maybe trying to defend jd? That was from D1, by the way. Also townread Doof on D2.
So, what that boils down to is that almost everyone that gimmepie has expressed opinions about is either dead or confirmed town, but it may be that he slipped jd, Newtsie, or EC in there to help out a scum. Of the three, I'm most wary of jd, ambivalent towards Newtsie, and curious about EC.