Mafia Madness: Sight [Game Over]

[Killua]

Let's do this we lynvh JD and every one invest let's say... Gimmepie and Bard because Bard is the easiest name for me to type.

 

[Nimsy]

[Kill] jdthebud
If you're town then it's a sacrifice we need to make to help people determine their sanity. If you're maf, then hahahahaha take that. Also, fos on the people who have posted so far this phase trying to point us away from jd.

The phase post basically confirmed Jd, I'm against lynching a semi-confirmed innocent.
So If Jd is lynched and turns up inno, which I'm pretty sure he will, then I suggest everyone look at JaDe.
Being so adamant to lynch a basically confirmed innocent, and then trying to cast those against the lynch in a bad light is very suss.

 

[gimmepie]

In comes Nimsy with the logic.

 

[JaDe.X105]

It's not logic if we all agreed that we would investigate the person and then lynch them the next day... And again, there is no confirmation that Klippy was investigating jd.

Klippy had just looked into the soul of another townsman.

How in any way does this confirm jd? As I already stated, Klippy was suggesting we investigate different people the previous day, so there is no guarantee that he investigated jd last night. jd very well could be inno, but until we know for sure it won't help us determine our sanity.

Nimsy I already refuted all your arguments in a previous post.

Guys, first off no where in the phase post is it stated that Klippy looked at jd. Klippy was the one that was suggesting we split into groups and investigate different people. We can't guarantee jd's town from that.
Second, since it's only Day 2, no one can guarantee what kind of Seer they are, especially since most people probably hadn't investigated the people who are dead. We need to compare our "Seer" results to the official dead confirmation. Only a handful of people had investigated Mana or Klippy N0; so going off of the chart I made the other day you few players can guess at what your sanity is, but no one can be 100% confident in what their sanity is. It literally takes at minimum 3 report comparisons to determine a sanity, and even then it might be a very unfortunate RNG Confused Seer that randomly aligns to look like another type of Seer.
Third, THE ENTIRE POINT OF EVERYONE INVESTIGATING JD WAS SO THAT WHEN WE LYNCH HIM THE FOLLOWING DAY, EVERYONE GETS 1 STEP
CLOSER TO DETERMINING THEIR SANITY (see my second point about needing 3 report comparisons)!

 

[Nakuzami]

Also, may I point out that "townsman" is in no way a synonym for "innocent." The mafia are townspeople too. They're just scummy townspeople.

 

[Nimsy]

Since we all agreed to investigate Jd, we can assume that's who klippy investigated.
The phase post referred to him as town.

But go ahead, lynch a basically confirmed innocent, give the mafia even more of an upper hand.

Everyone investigate JaDe this night, please.

 

[Nakuzami]

The phase post referred to him as town.

Also, may I point out that "townsman" is in no way a synonym for "innocent." The mafia are townspeople too. They're just scummy townspeople.

 

[Superjolt]

I thought the point of this lynch was to help everyone figure out the sanity of their roles, regardless of what jd's alignment is?

What exactly is strange about JaDe continuing to follow through with a plan he came up with on D1?

 

[jdthebud]

My interpretation was that Lycan was trying to help us poor sods out with that phase post.

 

[Lycanthropy]

There is approximately 20 hours left in this day phase. Don't forget your votes, people!
These people still need to vote: aeternum, Ash, Bardothren, Davepetasprite^2, Desinishon, El Héroe Oscuro, gimmepie, GreyBidoof, jdthebud, Kaneki!!!, Nakuzami, NightKrow, Nimsy, Superjolt, Wicked3DS
A bold name means you have to vote today or the consequences might be horrendous death.

 

[GreyBidoof]

[kill] GreyBidoof

I mean, why not

 

[NightKrow]

[Kill] jdthebud unless anyone has a better plan?

 

[Nakuzami]

I'm gonna help JaDe finish his plan, even if it won't benefit me personally.

Kill jdthebud

 

[Salzorrah]

[kill] jdthebud

sorry jd :(

 

[Wicked3DS]

[KILL] JaDe.X105

Sorry, have to disagree here.

 

[Superjolt]

snip

Naku, how do you feel about Nimsy attacking JaDe, and how do you feel about Nimsy in general so far?

My interpretation was that Lycan was trying to help us poor sods out with that phase post.

I mean, this is assuming that Klippy checked you, but seeing this post kind of suggests otherwise. Aside from that, I do think you're inno (and I got an inno on you last night), and I was leaning town on you already on D1 (because I see such little scum motivation in being first to claim a result the way you did).

The thing is though, JaDe's plan revolves around getting a definitive flip from your lynch to make it easier for everyone to figure out what sanity they have.

[Kill] jdthebud unless anyone has a better plan?

This is the other thing, no one else is coming up with any alternatives or other plans. This is what kind of bugs me about Nimsy. I don't like the way Nimsy is sort of indirectly attacking JaDe. She thinks jd is inno - ok fine, but she doesn't offer an alternate lynch target. And if she thinks JaDe is likely to be scum if jd flips inno, then she should also assume that JaDe was already setting up a mislynch on jd during D1.

[kill] jdthebud

Kind of want to hear some input on this from some of the others, namely Desinishon and Wicked (and also Ash and aeternum who have yet to post anything), and I like El Héroe's .gifs but he needs to make a post that's actually game-relevant

EDIT:

[KILL] JaDe.X105

Sorry, have to disagree here.

Why?

 

[Killua]

kill jdthebud

 

[Nimsy]

[kill] ash
I'd rather go for an inactive.

 

[Sonata]

[kill] el hero

 

[Wicked3DS]

Why?

It seems like a very elaborate plan after just two days of information. We need more investigations to be done. However, it's not like we have a choice in the matter either, since we're not allowed to just no vote and do research apparently...