Map Rating/Review Thread

[The Shadow Knight]

Nice! I like the remake, but i can see some errors.
8/10

Ummm nice, some errors but-7/10


Great!
I can see slight errors and think that the grass pal is abit dark.
ohwell-- 7.5/10

In a-map the flower tiles all look like that,if that's one of the thingies you saw.(I edited the map in paint to make it look the way it appears in the emulator)

 

[OsherStyle]

Nice comments zel;)
And,
Its been a while since i posted any maps so here goes:
Game:FR(Its a pokemon Eruption map)
Name: Route 2
Map:
Hope you like it ;)
P.S DONT STEAL THE PALS PLEASE!!!

10/10 thet awsome ! i love thet

 

[Ooka]

Well, I know that everyone is going to be rating this map badly because of the palette and probably not even considering the map but this IS supposed to be a Viridian CIty redo.

 

[destinedjagold]

I love the trees.., but the grass is brightly colored, though... Some mountain and pond edges' errors are to be seen... The right side of the map is kinda empty... The rest is looking awesome...

7/10... the grass kinda hurts my eyes... T_T

 

[OsherStyle]

nice, its too empty..
8/10

 

[Ooka]

5 buildings, 4 patches of grass, a mountain, and a lake is empty? Wow, then I guess the whole game is kinda empty huh?

 

[Geeked]

Please rate

 

[Ooka]

Well, the normal grass tiles look a little plain, but other than that it looks good.

7/10

 

[destinedjagold]

A little mountain edge error on top... Everyhing else looks oky. 7/10

 

[spenceroone3]

Name: Yung stunna's starter map
Rating: 8/10
Reason: I would like to live there, it looks pretty comfortable.
Suggestions: Use block editor on the back of the mountain.

 

[Binary]

10/10 thet awsome ! i love thet

Thanks for the coment*Yay!10/10 8D*

Well, I know that everyone is going to be rating this map badly because of the palette and probably not even considering the map but this IS supposed to be a Viridian CIty redo.

Ummm i think the pal is abit bright, and i can see a couple of tile errors on the pond etc. And the right side is abit empty,
else i like it. 8/10

Please rate

Ummm i think its abit empty, and you need to add a little more creativity into it ;)
7/10

 

[spenceroone3]

Very small map today, sorry, but here it is:

Spoiler:

.:Game:.
Pokemon Firered
Hack is Poke Story
.:Map name:.
Route 203
.:Brief Description:.
This is route 203 from Sinnoh. It is a couple of years earlier then when humans first came about (They hadn't evolved from Primeapes and Infernapes yet) but Pokemon like having straight grasses. Their is only one event on the whole map, and that is just below the ledge, which is a pidgey that gives you a Potion. Personally I believe this is one of my very best maps. Please comment.

 

[thethethethe]

@spenceroone3: Personally I'm not a fan of remake maps. I just don't think that a lot of the nintendo made maps don't look 'the best'. Sorry, 6.5/10(added .5 because I can't see any errors)

Well Here's my map.

 

[Blazichu]

@thethethethe: I noticed one error in the map, the door window is yellow <_< Also the map reminds me of Pallet alot...but I'll give it a 7/10 ;)

 

[thethethethe]

Thanks Blazichu, I'll fix that palette. I thought it looked familiar but I guess I just couldn't pick it. Well I've got a couple more maps.

 

[cooley]

Those are maps in your hack? They look Great!
1st - 9/10
2nd - 8/10 ' errors on the bottom edges of lakes.

Very small map today, sorry, but here it is:

Spoiler:

.:Game:.
Pokemon Firered
Hack is Poke Story
.:Map name:.
Route 203
.:Brief Description:.
This is route 203 from Sinnoh. It is a couple of years earlier then when humans first came about (They hadn't evolved from Primeapes and Infernapes yet) but Pokemon like having straight grasses. Their is only one event on the whole map, and that is just below the ledge, which is a pidgey that gives you a Potion. Personally I believe this is one of my very best maps. Please comment.

That looks exactly like That route in D/P, you know what it's called....xD
Anyways: 8/10

 

[Johnny3]

Well Here's my map.

Hey TTTT I really don't mind this one I like how you placed the trees ( realistically no tree is lined up with another) Nice work, The hedges down the top look good, You have unique style.

 

[cooley]

@johnny: I don't see a map.

::.My Map.::

Just a map, nothing special. Don't tell me the road hurts your eyes....xD

 

[thethethethe]

Those are maps in your hack? They look Great!
1st - 9/10
2nd - 8/10 ' errors on the bottom edges of lakes.


That looks exactly like That route in D/P, you know what it's called....xD
Anyways: 8/10

They aren't from my hack but I might oinclude one of them.

@cooley's Map. The road hurts my eyes.(Just kidding) You need to palette edit the grass of the black road tiles. And an error above the door on the thing in the mddle. Also you need to palette edit the corners of the lake. And a little block editor problem on the tree below the lake.
6 out of ten.

Well here's a map that IS in my hack. My version of Olivine.

 

[Gerri Shin]

This is a really old map I made back when I was a mapper. just thought I'd let you all take a gander at it.
(yes, I used Zel's Tileset, only because its the best in my eyes so far, don't knock it b/c of the set)

Spoiler: