Map Rating/Review Thread

[Chimchar 9]

I've reached that goal, by taking my time, and listen to other people comment who don't know what they're saying

a map is what values from custom to awesome.

You need to check if it's square, add some roads, and mostly add the misc. stuff. that map if I did what I said would take 1 hour with using ctrl and right click on the grosser, since I never do that.

ok then i will do that thank's im going to listen im going to do a town now so look out for it and iv deleated the other one cause it wasnt good anyway i was racing my friend see who could do the longest map but anyay thanks im nearly done with the town i started it yesterday so its nearly done

 

[Ryousha]

I've reached that goal, by taking my time, and listen to other people comment who don't know what they're saying

a map is what values from custom to awesome.

You need to check if it's square, add some roads, and mostly add the misc. stuff. that map if I did what I said would take 1 hour with using ctrl and right click on the grosser, since I never do that.

 

[Chimchar 9]

iv just made a town so here it is it look's much better

please rate

 

[Momoko]

@Riolu 9 even though the path covers pretty much the whole town, It's too wide IMO and distratcs me from other stuff O_O,not to mention the tile errors...and how I like it except for the path and the small Pond that looks rather boring*square* 7.5/10

 

[Chimchar 9]

@Riolu 9 even though the path covers pretty much the whole town, It's too wide IMO and distratcs me from other stuff O_O,not to mention the tile errors...and how I like it except for the path and the small Pond that looks rather boring*square* 7.5/10

the path doesnt take up the whole path and where are the tile error's

 

[Tyrantrum]

iv just made a town so here it is it look's much better

please rate

Add like too flowers above the lake and ur good! ;)...9.5/10

 

[[K]evin "The Last Eeveon"]

Another Pic

Heres Another Pic From Me Enjoy.Oh And Forget The Tree I Fixed That Already

Spoiler:

 

[Momoko]

Sorry, Kevin33193, But I'm not going to rate that one :P it's much too...large and confusing..I'll leave that to someone else. anyhow, I am posting one of my own.
I don't know why,but I hate this so much...O_O

Spoiler:

 

[[K]evin "The Last Eeveon"]

@ Momoko Its Ok. I Know Lol
Well I Got To Admit I Like Your Mapping Its Really Good I Can See Why you Hate It Lol

Id Give It A 9/10

 

[Tyrantrum]

Heres Another Pic From Me Enjoy.Oh And Forget The Tree I Fixed That Already

Spoiler:

I see a couple tile errors.
Too much unused space and hedges shouldn't really look like that! :P
...8.5/10

Sorry, Kevin33193, But I'm not going to rate that one :P it's much too...large and confusing..I'll leave that to someone else. anyhow, I am posting one of my own.
I don't know why,but I hate this so much...O_O

Spoiler:

I see a few tile errors and some unused space...8.5/10

Here's a map by me! ^^

Spoiler:

Hope u like!

 

[[K]evin "The Last Eeveon"]

@ eeveon Well Lets See I Really Dont Understand Whats With The Mart Lol. And The Cutting Tree Is On Top Of The Bigger Tree. Lol I Know It Goes Below I See No Errors For Now

9.5/10

 

[Chimchar 9]

I see a couple tile errors.
Too much unused space and hedges shouldn't really look like that! :P
...8.5/10


I see a few tile errors and some unused space...8.5/10

Here's a map by me! ^^

Spoiler:

Hope u like!

good mapping Eeveon whats with the poke mart i love the tile's aswell i give this 8.5 out of 10

 

[Tyrantrum]

I deleted my post to post a map I re-edited for riolu 9's hack, Pokemon Mystic Moon.

 

[Darthatron]

I deleted my post to post a map I re-edited for riolu 9's hack, Pokemon Mystic Moon.

It's pretty good, however I don't like the Palette that much. I also see some tile errors, the paths for example, they are the wrong colors. :P Also, in the water, the corners seem to be non existent. :S Everything else is pretty good, though.

7/10

------------------

Now, can somebody please rate my map? :D

In case you can't tell, it's a maze. >_>

 

[Tyrantrum]

The maze is nicely made! :)
I like the way u put obstacles in front of some items.
Very good...10/10

 

[Luck]

Whoa!
its a nice map darthatron, but just because its a maze, it doesn't mean it has to be bushes.
you should've added some trees and more ledges to make it seem more natural.
7.5/10 for having nice mountains and a confusing maze.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Now, can somebody please rate my map? :D

In case you can't tell, it's a maze. >_>

I'd be honoured to. :D
Obviously, those guys are all lost...
I don't see anything wrong, I love the mountains...
But...why are they hedges?

Meh, 9/10

 

[Darthatron]

The maze is nicely made! :)
I like the way u put obstacles in front of some items.
Very good...10/10

Thankyou, very much. :)

Whoa!
its a nice map darthatron, but just because its a maze, it doesn't mean it has to be bushes.
you should've added some trees and more ledges to make it seem more natural.
7.5/10 for having nice mountains and a confusing maze.

Thanks for the high rating. :)

I was going to make some custom tiles, like stone hedges, but then I got lazy. xD

I'd be honoured to. :D
Obviously, those guys are all lost...
I don't see anything wrong, I love the mountains...
But...why are they hedges?

Meh, 9/10

Honored, huh? :D

As I said above, I was planning on making custom tiles, but due to laziness, I didn't. :P

--------------------

Thanks everyone, for the kind words.

 

[EarthsVisitor]

Meh. This map does not have much going for it.
For one, you obviously have not played it. No one is going to go into the paths the lead into the trainer if they can obviously see it leads to the trainers, which your map allows them to do. Also, it feels weird with only bushes. Add trees and other things as boundaries.
Feels random and unplanned.
The shape of the overall map is nice I think.

4/10

 

[Ryousha]

Made in 30 minutes to challenge Trace, and another guy,

I got second place for such a forest route.


route 2 of Dark Era B)