should ash have a female main rival

  • 16
    Posts
    8
    Years
    • Seen Feb 15, 2017
    I think it's about time ash had a main rival who happens be a girl basically the complete opposite to Bianca
    I would she her being a tough skilled trainer with out being a bitch a sort of Zoe but less sort stereotypical tough girl still having some girly qualities
     
     
    After hearing what Pokemon Generations did with only showing the games' male protagonists and leaving the females out, it seems likely that Pokemon anime writers (granted I know Generations had a different team but it can apply to the main anime as well) are biased when it comes to treatment of female characters.

    If you pay attention to every female main game protagonist who appeared in the anime (main examples being May, Dawn and Serena) they were all shoved into doing a role that was girly by default (aka Contests and Showcases) which unfortunately made them into frilly, girly-girl stereotypes.

    The writers also have huge preference to only putting Ash's strength on par with male characters, which explains why pretty much every rival he's had has been male. Bianca was also unfortunately subject to the girly-girl curse, which is why she's ditzy and never managed to battle Ash a lot.

    In fact, if you look at all the notable Gym-challenging characters, they are male-dominated. The only female who I recall was even collecting Gym badges was Lyra, who weirdly was the only female game protagonist not to fall to the girly-girl female character curse.

    So basically, if you're a female character from the games, expect yourself to be butchered heavily in the anime and essentially denied from doing any major quests like the Gyms.
     
    Last edited:
    Hells yeah.

    That's why I'm hoping Lillie becomes a trainer in SM.

    Like seriously you can have almost 50% of gym leaders as female, almost 50% of E4 members as female, almost 50% of champions as female and yet you can't have one female trainer in the main cast?

    Come on.
     
    Yes he really needs a main rival that is a female. May should have been that rival, but they changed it. Heck in the Manga Blue, Sapphire/May, and Platinum/Dawn all took on the gyms though Blue was the only one in the League.

    Misty was ok, but she was not a true rival and older character tend to be worse than the new ones, most of the time. Misty was a great rival, but I don't think we can say she is a real rival. Iris is in the same boat, but they did not give her character anything in the anime other than having an annoying line that she said in almost every episode.

    Manga has done such a better job with the female characters. And I mean a GREAT Job. I wish the anime would get some tips from the Manga writer.

    Mallow seems like she will be a good rival if she actually does some battling. I think Lana will be like all the other females. Lillie can go either way.
     
    I don't see why he couldn't have a female main rival. Both of May's main rivals were male and one of Dawn's rivals (although Kenny is more friend than rival) was male.
     
    I would definitely love to see Ash have a female rival. I was actually hoping Lillie would take on that role in the Sun Moon anime, but from what I hear she can't even touch Pokemon....
     
    As long as she's well written, and not The Girl, I don't care. Imo, the only good female rival at all was Ursula, anyway.

    Just give us well written female rivals for Ash, and you're fine.
     
    He should... but I'd rather have a well written and threatening(In battle... kinda like how Alain, Gary, and Paul where) rival, whether its male or female as long as the character has the traits of a entertaining rival... I'm good.
     
    I agree that there should be a main female rival, i mean its the 21st century, times are different from when they started pokemon. They keep it the same through tall regions, but they shouldnt, its time for a change.
     
    Back
    Top