If we let it have a shortcut based on the principle of how active it's been over x amount of time, are we drawing a mark? Because then other threads who manage to reach the same popularity or importance (important enough for a crowd of people to be debating over whether or not it deserves a shortcut lol), should we not give those threads shortcuts too?
I just find it to be a bit too specific for no reason. Hey all of a sudden the DCC gets a shortcut on the first page as a memorial! It's so random. If shortcuts were something to be introduced to PC, I would much rather be able to choose myself where I get to shortcut. If not, then I don't really think any particular threads should be getting any favouritism over other threads, regardless of how popular and for how long it has been lasting.
And I can't help but feel it's a bit ironic that the one thread we choose to praise at PC is one that probably discusses Pokemon the least.