The Darkest Dungeon

I'm gonna agree with the above and say Melody was the Hag. It makes the most sense.

Things I noticed:

- No Arbalist mention today.
- When the Necromancer said "it seems you belong to another" to the "dying man" before the Shambler came to finish them off - I assume this dying man was Absol, but is this flavor text or can someone negate the Necromancer's attack at night? That would be swell.​
 
Okay, this means that Zehn was telling the truth as was Arbo, although it is worth noting that Melody does seem to have been the Hag and that two people took 0 last night.

I'm not totally sure if I consider the people who voted for Zehn as scum though, it seems possible that at least one just wasn't buying his constantly changing and contradicting claims. Still something we might want to look into though.

I'm also still extremely suss of how quiet Gunner has been this game, it is extremely unlike her.
 
gimmepie said:
I'm also still extremely suss of how quiet Gunner has been this game, it is extremely unlike her.
Click to expand...

Well TBF she is in every other mafia game (so she might just be invested in the others) and hasn't been too active on skype either. How active is she on the other games?
 
There's some strangeness with the damage on D2 again. I cannot account the two damage Rozureido took to any attack made yesterday, as was with Mana the day before. It may have the same source...
You got any explanation Rozureido?

I don't think gps attack isn't much above 22. It may, but ... Spectrum, JonnyMustang, jdthebud, Ullion, rozureido, myself and gp attacked zeffy yesterday, with jdthebud delivering the death blow. Spectrum claims to have an attack of 4, Jonny claims he has 3, jdthebut dealt 5 damage yesterday, but as he did the last blow if damage taken is counted he might have dealt only 1, as far as we know, Ullion said she got more than average, so let's go with 5, I told you, mine increased slightly above that of normal villagers, rozureidos is unknown, but as long as we assume it's not healing, let's stick with 1 for this estimation.
That's atleast 17 damage on others, much more likely 20 or more. So a maximum of 28 Attack on the Giant. It could easily also be 22.
Gimmepie could you confirm your attack value, please?

Getting to the main point: Yesterday Arsonist took 6 damage. marz attacked and killed him. marz seid he has an attack of 9... The day before Foxrally took 22 damage and died by an at of the Giant. Fox very much implied, that he was a normal villager. As such he should have had 18 HP, not 22.
So at least one of those two is lying. Either fox "missed" to tell us which role he was before he died or marz "exaggerated" the amount of damage he does.
 
Gunner just hasn't been able to be on that often and most of you know this, so stop trying to suss her out so foolishly please.
 
Just a thing. Now everyone knows my role, everyone should be able to say who I use it not. I know gimmepie wanted me to heal him, but as I'm sitting on 5hp if nothing urgent comes up I would like to heal myself. Klippy confirmed to me as well I could use it on myself
 
faer said:
Gimmepie could you confirm your attack value, please?
Click to expand...

My attack value is supposedly 20, my HP is significantly higher. According to Klippy, I can one-shot villagers as well as several other roles. However there seems to be 2 damage done to Fox that didn't come from me, unless my attack is actually 22 and Klippy messed up. Either way, I probably should have checked my role message and re-confirmed earlier so sorry about that.

Nakuzami said:
Gunner just hasn't been able to be on that often and most of you know this, so stop trying to suss her out so foolishly please.
Click to expand...

I actually did not know this. I assumed I'd just been missing her on Skype.

Zehn said:
Just a thing. Now everyone knows my role, everyone should be able to say who I use it not. I know gimmepie wanted me to heal him, but as I'm sitting on 5hp if nothing urgent comes up I would like to heal myself. Klippy confirmed to me as well I could use it on myself
Click to expand...

You probably need it more than I do, so use your discretion. Let's just note though, that if you heal five and only have five HP left, that only brings you up to ten HP so you're still an extremely easy target.
 
Okay Zehn, whether you heal yourself or not, it's completely unnecessary for you to heal GP at all. So don't.
 
could we also not save potential scum again if you don't feel right about killing them please and thanks
 
Well Gunner's being quite inactive on Skype as well. Well, at least for now we know not to attack Gunner, even if I already dealt some damage on her. Forgive me for dealing 5 damage on you, Gunner. ^^;

gimmepie said:
My attack value is supposedly 20, my HP is significantly higher. According to Klippy, I can one-shot villagers as well as several other roles. However there seems to be 2 damage done to Fox that didn't come from me, unless my attack is actually 22 and Klippy messed up. Either way, I probably should have checked my role message and re-confirmed earlier so sorry about that.
Click to expand...

I figured that your attack is 20, 'cause 22 is quite the odd number to have. Plus, there's also the unexplained 2 damage on me from that day. From the looks of it, there might be another role that is capable of doing day damage.
 
Heal yourself Zehn :).

Also, Faer, I think you're referring to the damage to Candy. Is it possible someone gets to vote privately and we've missed them amongst so many players?
 
Milotic said:
Well Gunner's being quite inactive on Skype as well. Well, at least for now we know not to attack Gunner, even if I already dealt some damage on her. Forgive me for dealing 5 damage on you, Gunner. ^^;
Click to expand...

No we don't.
We just know that we shouldn't attack her for her inactivity, she could easily still be scum. There's been roles that haven't acted every night it seems after all.



I figured that your attack is 20, 'cause 22 is quite the odd number to have. Plus, there's also the unexplained 2 damage on me from that day. From the looks of it, there might be another role that is capable of doing day damage.
Click to expand...

All roles can do day damage, but this suggests there might be one that can do so outside their normal attack.
 
I want to heal myself, and I still think I will even though it's just to 10 HP. I'm pretty sure I have the lowest health at the moment
 
gimmepie said:
No we don't.
We just know that we shouldn't attack her for her inactivity, she could easily still be scum. There's been roles that haven't acted every night it seems after all.

All roles can do day damage, but this suggests there might be one that can do so outside their normal attack.
Click to expand...

True enough, it's still not certain that Gunner is not a scum, but attacking someone based on their activity is still not the best move anyway. x:

That's exactly what I was going to say. Forgive me if my words sounded differently, but yeah. There's a good chance that there are roles that get to deal extra damage during the day. It's a plausible explanation on why me and Fox got extra damage that day.

Perhaps there are people that got the 2 random damage as well yesterday... idk, I haven't really done the damage calculations. Maybe someone can go check if it's true?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top