The Darkest Dungeon

Sopheria said:
I didn't receive anything like that, which makes me think that either only certain people were affected by it, or that it affected everyone and only certain people were notified, for whatever reason.



Are you able to tell us why you suspect marz of being one of those roles? If you don't think it's safe to reveal, it's cool, but it'd be good to know if we should go ahead and vote with you.
Click to expand...

Sure I can tell you, I'm almost dead anyway. And monsters will most likely being going for greybidoof tonight anyway. My attack is 3, I attacked marz. Ruling out the roles that people have claimed and some that are proven, and the roles that were healed/took less than 3 damage I have made a list of the most likely roles. If anyone can disprove any of these please tell us. But right now I think it would be a good risk to take to attack him, 75% chance is pretty good.
 
gimmepie said:
What do you think of this? Does this suggest that JD has something to do with the Necromancer? I know that I took 15 damage last night after attacking him, even though the previous nights nothing was done to me.
Click to expand...
I don't know why you took 15 damage, but I have nothing to do with the Necromancer.

If marz is suss that would be a good target for your attack today.
 
Speaking of "attack", we really need to get things moving. This game is clearly designed to punish defensive play (as was exhibited last night), and, as a hero, evil, terror, etc.- keeping all of these threats around will only make the coming floors more painful. Random attacks are easy, but they're gonna make things worse for everyone in the long run.
 
Wizardman11 said:
Sure I can tell you, I'm almost dead anyway. And monsters will most likely being going for greybidoof tonight anyway. My attack is 3, I attacked marz. Ruling out the roles that people have claimed and some that are proven, and the roles that were healed/took less than 3 damage I have made a list of the most likely roles. If anyone can disprove any of these please tell us. But right now I think it would be a good risk to take to attack him, 75% chance is pretty good.
Click to expand...
I would also want to wait for his input, as well as Lawliettas. At least until the 24h remaining notice... Though I'd definitly take the risk, if neccessary.

Rozureido said:
ah i see
everyone ignore rozu :(
Click to expand...
I'm very sorry, but I didn't notice anything that needs to be answered in your posts. You might wanna post it again. Lotsa people get ignored quite often. Me too.

machomuu said:
Speaking of "attack", we really need to get things moving. This game is clearly designed to punish defensive play (as was exhibited last night), and, as a hero, evil, terror, etc.- keeping all of these threats around will only make the coming floors more painful. Random attacks are easy, but they're gonna make things worse for everyone in the long run.
Click to expand...
I've been trying to suggest that the investigative Hero roles should be more open with their info. It seems, they don't agree... I'm currently trying to find something to tip of on Bacteriophage. But I can't really find anything for or against him. Any other opinions on his behavior?
I do know you're all very sceptical of not proven kills, but if we don't start focusing our damage, it's going to kill us.
 
Right, I can confirm now (after getting a pm from Klippy) that the reason I lost 15 health is actually because of the Barkeep.

Zehn, I would be happy to take your healing but right now I think it would be better served being spent on Ullion or GreyDoof.

I'd like to hear from Lawli also, but I'm still uncertain about JD. That paragraph in the night phase is not doing him favours and I don't think he's provided a satisfactory defence. So I'll probably be voting Lawli tonight if she hasn't responded, but if she comes in and provides a better defence than jd I think I'll vote him.
 
Well then.

It would seem that I have been revealed, and by one my fellow heroes, no less. Thanks Mr. Highwayman. >:/

Sopheria said:
Also, now that we know you're the Man-at-Arms GB, can you tell us what the "machinations of the darkness" are that you were unable to protect from night 0? Mind you, only tell us if you feel that the information will help the heroes :)
Click to expand...

Anyways, to answer this, I have no idea what I failed to protect. Hopefully, now that I am exposed, someone with a protective role will provide some support tonight, so my role isn't wasted. :)
 
gimmepie said:
Right, I can confirm now (after getting a pm from Klippy) that the reason I lost 15 health is actually because of the Barkeep.

Zehn, I would be happy to take your healing but right now I think it would be better served being spent on Ullion or GreyDoof.

I'd like to hear from Lawli also, but I'm still uncertain about JD. That paragraph in the night phase is not doing him favours and I don't think he's provided a satisfactory defence. So I'll probably be voting Lawli tonight if she hasn't responded, but if she comes in and provides a better defence than jd I think I'll vote him.
Click to expand...
What paragraph are you talking about? I told you, I'm not a bad guy. Why are you suspicious of me?
 
Hm, well at least we learned a few things tonight. I just hope there's someone who can protect GreyBidoof.

So, do we have an agreement on who we should attack before the day ends? I'm thinking that out of Lawli and jd, we should attack whichever one gimmepie doesn't attack, since there's somewhat of a case against both of them right now.
 
Okay so I noticed that Lycan said something about me being an evil??? Ngl, this stressed me out a bit so I checked my messages to see if I had somehow got a new role
However since this is not the case, I don't really understand how Lycan got his information, since there is no way I am anything but a villager. ._.
As you all know, I had 20 health and have 2 attack- that's my proof and I'm afraid I can't do any better.
The thing is, I don't feel like Lycan is lying, and it seems a bit too out of the blue to be a scummy strategy, so I'm inclined to think there's been some sort of mistake (like you know the cop that gets a mistaken report in EM? it might be that)
 
faer said:
Just reminding you that there is no more normal villagers. There is 38 special roles for 38 players. All villagers have been appointed a role.
So having stats of 20HP and 2 attack is... well just that, but definitly no excuse.



...two nights in a row?
Click to expand...

Also about that, I wasn't there when Klippy told villagers to PM him with a number (if you remember I didn't vote on that day as well) so I never actually got a role. It's worth considering some people with roles have died, too.
 
Lawlietta said:
Also about that, I wasn't there when Klippy told villagers to PM him with a number (if you remember I didn't vote on that day as well) so I never actually got a role. It's worth considering some people with roles have died, too.
Click to expand...
I find this pretty hard to believe. After all, there is no "Villager" anymore, so there's no way you can just be a generic one.

Though you weren't there that day (mostly), I doubt Klippy wouldn't assign you a role if you didn't send in a number. After all, you're still a villager, just a named one. More, it wouldn't much make sense for Klippy to keep the information from you because, from an IC standpoint, it'd be pretty damn strange if you didn't know what you were.
 
GreyBidoof said:
Well then.
It would seem that I have been revealed, and by one my fellow heroes, no less. Thanks Mr. Highwayman. >:/

Anyways, to answer this, I have no idea what I failed to protect. Hopefully, now that I am exposed, someone with a protective role will provide some support tonight, so my role isn't wasted. :)
Click to expand...
Hey, now that you've been exposed anyway -.- is there some hints you can share? E.g. I was guessing, you might have been protecting the Brawler in Night 1 since he took -0 damage. Any leads to his identity?

gimmepie said:
I'd like to hear from Lawli also, but I'm still uncertain about JD. That paragraph in the night phase is not doing him favours and I don't think he's provided a satisfactory defence. So I'll probably be voting Lawli tonight if she hasn't responded, but if she comes in and provides a better defence than jd I think I'll vote him.
Click to expand...
...which paragraph and what are you reading into it?

Sopheria said:
Hm, well at least we learned a few things tonight. I just hope there's someone who can protect GreyBidoof.
So, do we have an agreement on who we should attack before the day ends? I'm thinking that out of Lawli and jd, we should attack whichever one gimmepie doesn't attack, since there's somewhat of a case against both of them right now.
Click to expand...
Right now I don't see a case against JD, except gp not trusting him. But Gimme is not a Hero and there's no proof. So there's no more a case against JD, then there is against Cheshire Cat:
Cheshire Cat said:
[Attack] Jdthebud
He's probably going to die anyway so why not?
Click to expand...
Totally scummy reason?


Hey JD, just wondering, after you got attacked by three people yesterday, did you get attacked at night as well?
 
There were 9 villagers and 9 new roles iirc. Lawli's defense against Wizard seems pretty suss too, since she's not accusing him of lying but assuming his role is manipulated.

Eh.

[attack] Lawlietta
 
Hm...attacking does seem the attractive option.

Lawlietta, anything you want to come clean about? Zehn's not on and who knows who'll strike? Well, probably me. 5 Sleepless nights in close to a row means I don't know when I'll be on tonight, and I've at least mostly committed to not randomly attacking today, so I'm liable to lose more by not taking this opportunity.
 
The part I'm talking about is this one

One among them fell victim earlier in the day to the machinations of the Prophet, but the Giant had found the corpse mutilated in the Darkness, its eyes popped out and filled with maggots and flies.
Click to expand...

This has to have come from something during the day since it was from the change to night and I don't have any night abilities let alone an investigative one.

We only get one attack during the day, I attacked JD. I admit that this isn't the strongest of cases, however there's something suss here because jd isn't dead. He's taken a lot of damage but he's very much so still alive (indicating a power role). Since he was described as a corpse though, it stands to reason that the Necromancer might have something to do with him... although it should be noted it looks like he was targeted by this prophet character.
 
gimmepie said:
The part I'm talking about is this one
One among them fell victim earlier in the day to the machinations of the Prophet, but the Giant had found the corpse mutilated in the Darkness, its eyes popped out and filled with maggots and flies.
Click to expand...
This has to have come from something during the day since it was from the change to night and I don't have any night abilities let alone an investigative one.

We only get one attack during the day, I attacked JD. I admit that this isn't the strongest of cases, however there's something suss here because jd isn't dead. He's taken a lot of damage but he's very much so still alive (indicating a power role). Since he was described as a corpse though, it stands to reason that the Necromancer might have something to do with him... although it should be noted it looks like he was targeted by this prophet character.
Click to expand...
Ok, now I get what you mean. There is something pretty suss about this paragraph, BUT the corpse it's talking about is Spectrums:
Klippy said:
The Prophet grinned a toothless grin, his gums and few teeth remaining were covered in black debris and maggots.
"You're coming with me, dead man."
He let the man's body collapse to the ground, blood slathering the cobbles, and dragged him off...deep into the Darkness.
Click to expand...
It's pretty suss, that of all people you were to find the body after the Prophet did what it did, but it might as well be only some narrative?
I absolutly don't see any connection to jdthebud, except if you wanna frame him as being the Prophet himself. Which is ...pretty farfetched imho.
 
machomuu said:
I find this pretty hard to believe. After all, there is no "Villager" anymore, so there's no way you can just be a generic one.

Though you weren't there that day (mostly), I doubt Klippy wouldn't assign you a role if you didn't send in a number. After all, you're still a villager, just a named one. More, it wouldn't much make sense for Klippy to keep the information from you because, from an IC standpoint, it'd be pretty damn strange if you didn't know what you were.
Click to expand...

With the very some logic, I'd also like to point out Foxrally again. It's been a while, but it only struck me, when Spectrum was pointing out that there's as many roles as there's people. So I recounted and recounted the player and role lists here, the Night after day 1. And there is no space for a normal villager. It's 38 names on the role list and 38 names on the players list. We did not get any new players since then, did we? And it would be strange for someone to have two roles? (But then, who or what is the Kraken?)
But here we have Foxrally stating he's still a normal villager 12 hours later:
Foxrally said:
I just checked with klips, I'm not a necro minion, just a villager (again). Think of my past body as the one guy in every movie who has the wilhelm scream as he dies in a random hilarious way.
Click to expand...
 
So who should I heal guys? I won't be any use to heal gimmiepie ever (sorry) and I want to vote before I forget
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top