This or That, Pokemon Edition - Version 2.16!!!!

[Janp]

Given that GF is able to screw any interesting setting I would like them to destroy underwater one rather than outer space.

Be regular programmer working on Pokémon game, but have no influence on the content of the game OR make your own franchise inspired on Pokémon, but risking to be sued by Nintendo?

 

[Noblejanobii]

A toughy but given knock offs tend to slide by I'll take my chances with that.

Have Game Freak introduce three typed Pokémon or four stage evolutions (ie introducing Gorochu as the fourth and final stage to pichu)?

 

[Janp]

Four stage evolutions, as we already almost have them in Mega Evolutions. We also have three typed evolutions, but pssst!

New baby Pokémon OR new Dawn Stone evolution?

 

[mishy.]

I think a new dawn stone Pokemon would be neat!!

A better story but graphics stay the same quality. Or better graphics while story stays the same.

 

[Janp]

Better story with the graphics of Gen VII. I don't know why, but LGPE graphics seems ugly to me.

Gen VIII is Kanto-heavy OR Gen VIII is disaster and no one ever likes it.

 

[PageEmp]

Gen VIII being Kanto-heavy. duh, i'd rather have that than an actually bad game.

Talonflame or Toucannon?

 

[Janp]

Toucannon. Talonflame is overrated.

Fire-Type Pokémon based on a fork OR Water-Type Pokémon based on a spoon?

 

[Meadow]

A Fire-type (pitch)fork Pokémon sounds absolutely hilarious and I'd love to see that coming to life! xD

Would you rather see a 19th type introduced in the next generation, or a new once-per-battle mechanic like Z-Moves and Mega Evolution?

 

[L'Belle]

A 19th type. Fairy typing was cool, but I still would love to see a light type.

Water routes or Snowy Routes?

 

[CodeHelmet]

Snowy Routes, with one having the following theme(or something similar to it):

Spoiler:

Yes... I'm a vindictive person. Mountain paths have always given a Death Mountain feel to me, even back in Generation 1 with Rock Tunnel for example. Plus, Hoenn had too much Water apparently ;)

Hmm... New Mystery Dungeon Game or New Detective Pikachu game?

 

[Meadow]

I'd choose the new Mystery Dungeon game by a longshot! I've been dying to be able to play as Rowlet and Rockruff in the PMD games... :(

Pokémon figurines or Pokémon trading cards?

 

[Janp]

I have enough cards, so I'll take figurines.

Season and time-based Pokémon in next games, resulting in huge variety of Pokémon, but you might as well wait months to get the one you want OR only small number of Pokémon that can be caught all the time.

 

[mishy.]

huge variety i can get whenever especially since changing the time to try and cheat can be a hassle so meh. former is really good if you want to do like multiple runs (one for each season) or something like that.

playing competitively or playing casually

 

[CodeHelmet]

Casually. Whole point of games is to have fun and some people can take games way, way too seriously to the point where it ceases to be fun. I will admit that I fall into that category.

Any Pokemon you want with perfect stats, nature, ability or A Shiny Pokemon but with subpar stats, ability and nature?

 

[Meadow]

I'll go for the non-shiny Pokémon with perfect stats and stuff! I almost always prefer a Pokémon's regular palette over its shiny one, so it's a win-win for me!! :D

If Kalos is revisited 10 years from now, would you rather see X/Y remakes or a Z Version (at long last)?

 

[VisionofMilotic]

Z please!!

Receive a heart-scale valentine from Luvdisc or a present from Delibird?

 

[Meadow]

Luvdisc!! <3 Not only because it would feel more warm and fuzzy inside ahaha, but also because Delibird's presents could probably be dangerous. xD

A Pokémon based on the Grinch, or a Pokémon based on Mickey Mouse?

 

[Noblejanobii]

Definitely the grinch. Mix that with Krampus and you got a nasty christmas maniac.

Darker story options or an opt in nuzlocke mode

 

[VisionofMilotic]

Dark story options.

Grow up a hungry, homeless orphan alone in the streets or be raised by Ghetsis and Lusamine as your parents?

 

[Hyzenthlay]

Well... N and Lillie turned out okay, so I guess I would too if I went with option B! :P

Would you rather have a Pokémon/Zelda crossover or Pokémon crossed with something like Animal Crossing / Harvest Moon? :)