LOL I think Sparkin is very much town. I forgot one of my tells as Agent.
Voting L'Belle for now
[Unvote] Sparkin
[Vote] L'Belle
I've had that suspicion for a while now since D1.
Also thinking that GP is the one responsible for that spy message.
So, here's the thing, Sparkin is saying he's a Vanilla townie. However, you send to roles not players. Which means if Sparkin got a message as VT, I would also have gotten the same message and so would every other VT player. Unless, like in games Chura and/or I run, Agent and Spy can't message vanilla townies. This means Sparkin cannot be a Vanilla townie. So we have only four options here.
1. Sparkin is a town PR. He's lying about being a VT because he doesn't want to be lynched. Explains his reluctance to claim.
2. Both you and Sparkin are mafia. I doubt this though because the actual agent would have CC'd.
3. Sparkin is mafia and it is a coincidence that he used whatever codeword you sent.
4. Sparkin is VT and it is a coincidence that he used whatever codeword you sent.
I think we can rule out option two. Which leaves a 2/3 chance of Sparkin being a town role. With that being said, I am prepared to move my vote off of Sparkin for now.
[uncage] Sparkin
Moving along, the only players here I see as likely to do the poetry thing are aeternum and Nakuzami.
Maybe Gunner, but I don't think so. Of the three of them, I think Alvey is the most likely to send intentionally bad poetry. So I think aeternum is most likely the Spy.
So I'm going to go with
[cage] aeternum for the moment.
Assuming that Alvey is maf, I find it dubious that Pecilia could be a partner. This is because Alvey voted Pecilia earlier on without much reason to.
Now, having come to the conclusion that Sparkin has a higher chance of being town than maf, I'm not sure about L'Belle anymore. I
had been town reading him, but looking back I can see where Sparkin and Ishi are coming from.
You need to role claim immediately.
Looking at the remaining players I feel like Chura, Peci, Nicki and Gunner are probbaly innocent. That's not to say that they are, I just don't feel particularly inclined to scum lean them at this time. Sawsbuck and Miah however have just sheeped through and Josh/Naku have not been providing the kind of presence they are capable of.
So yeah, the way I see it the mafia is probably Aeternum, Sawsbuck, Miah and then Naku, Josh or L'Belle to round it off.