Merlin Mafia

I'm with Bard on this one - lynching no one again seems very counterproductive and it's kinda hard to trust what drewbie is doing back yet again.

[Lynch] drewthree411

I really hate no lynching but I don't think we really have anything then with no CC on Abby (which surprises me ngl, sorry Abby I was way off lol). I'd rather not go and accidentally lynch a PR or something and as much as I'd love to kill Drewbie again he could still be the Shade so that's a terrible idea.

[Reluctantly Abstains]

Edit: I feel the need to clarify by again I didn't mean me personally before some idiot jumps on that poor choice of words.

While I'll agree that drewthree being back is suss, if the Shade's solo-win from being lynched is still in effect then this would be giving away the win...

I want to say have Arthur claim and Gaius protect each night so that we could get more clears/guilties, but with Mordred still alive and being able to swap out any vest for a fake one, this would leave Arthur vulnerable during the day to gunshots... Soo maybe hold off that idea till Mordred is gone, at which point voodooMorgause would just need to be avoided(e-z 2 sp33k leik dis :P).

For the time being, [vote] no one

Mars™ said:

Hm...
FoS: mewnani
This usually raises a red flag for me, scum really don't like clearing people.

Click to expand...

That's a bit of an odd statement to make considering the mafia's rather strange choice of targets. I never indicated I didn't like people being cleared, or at least I don't think I did though I did neglect to mention there's 4 people clear that we know of, and 5 or 6 total counting the ones Arthur investigated assuming he didn't investigate anyone already cleared. I'm going to assume he'll make his presence known once he's dug up a mafia member seeing as how he hasn't claimed yet. I can't really say my wording helped all that much though so yeah, sorry about that. :(

Concerning the mafia specifically though I'm still befuddled. Zehn was replaced by drewbie before Morgana got her face mauled so I'm going to assume he was inactive since the beginning, leaving just two people in the mafia to think about targets and overall strategy. I still don't quite understand why drewbie was a Night 0 target, but I can understand their reasoning for trying to take Bard out on Night 1; he was one of the players who offered advice and was being observant of other people and attempting to piece together who the mafia might be. It ended badly of course because they couldn't possibly have known he'd trash them; they made a choice and RNG was ultimately against them, so they chose poorly. So who would benefit from both of them being removed from the game early on, and who would be inclined to take them out first?

_{And yeah late post is late. Who's Line is it Anyway happened, and I apologize. ><}

In the meantime I guess I'll vote to put drewbie to rest. If drewbie is the shade he wins by being lynched (I don't even get how that works seeing as how he's technically already dead but meh,) but at the monent I have a hard time determining his place in the mortal coil, let alone what he actually is. The only idea I got is from that bit about him being stained by Morgana's sins... could he have possibly inherited her power? I'm not sure what else it could mean.

[Lynch]drewthree411

[Lynch] No-one

I could change my vote to drewbie, but I'm unsure if he is the Shade again or not. For starters, the post does state he is the Shade, right? Secondly, the flavour text implies he is body-less atm and tainted by Morgana. I'm not sure about you guys, but wouldn't a Shade be considered body-less?

[Vote] No one it seems far too dangerous to vote for drew, but you guys can do whatever you want, I guess.

GUYS I JUST REALIZED SOMETHING...

We have quite a bit of evidence pointing to Abby, but there's more...

I kind of outed Abby being Siren in tDD2, maybe he killed me for revenge? That's the only incentive I can think of someone having to kill me, unless it was just a random mafia kill.

[Vote] Abby

Other than that, I don't understand why I'm getting a BW right now. Wasn't there just suspicion that I was the Shade yesterday?

Can we take a moment to appreciate that Nani has amazing taste in TV?

Also, I doubt writing in Leet or w/e is going to help anyone avoid the VL. Most GMs here will still let the curse hit you. I know I would.

I'm also not sure about drew3 is shade or not so for now I'll vote


[Vote] no one

Oh yeah.

I'd better vote.

[vote] No one at all...

I don't see a good reason to lynch drewbie, so

[Vote]No one

>:I I guess we're doing this, then

Vote No One

Actually the reason for my concern is not so much that drewbie might be the Shade, but that there somehow are two Shades in the game (one with a question mark). None of the roles say anything like this.

Still, I don't think it's a good idea to switch to drewbie so I'm going to keep my vote.

Another no lynch? Well, I guess the first one worked well, might as well try it again?

[Vote] No one

Maybe Bard won't eat them this time, maf should try hitting him again just to test it out...

JaDe.X105 said:

Maybe Bard won't eat them this time, maf should try hitting him again just to test it out...

Click to expand...

This is a very great idea!

Honestly this mafia should just give up now, they're doing really shit.
Seconding what Bard said, a claim would help narrow suspects a lot.

I wonder who our mysterious woman found. Arthur maybe?