The Darkest Dungeon

[Sopheria]

I could just tell you what I know

Or you could find it yourself for once instead of waiting for someone else to finally point it out :)

EDIT: Here are some expert resources for those who can't look back a day phase to find the posts
https://www.pokecommunity.com/posts/8940446/

https://www.pokecommunity.com/posts/8941936

We're not always going to assume that you're correct that these "clues" you're alluding to are legitimate, which is what makes the "I see something you don't see" game fruitless.

However, from the post about the hag, I'd say that this indicates either that the prophet gets a free kill whenever they correctly predict someone's death, or they get a free revenge kill when certain roles are killed, a la Lucifer in FDL. I'd lean more towards the former, since Melody's death was easily predictable (which would also mean that this hypothetical prediction ability goes by player rather than role).

 

[Bidoof FTW]

Flavor text doesn't exist in mafia.

It's all just a clue

yes it's a hyperbole but it's a good mindset to use

 

[machomuu]

Ah, this is definitely where past Mafia Knowledge would help. A free kill made sense enough and, really, was pretty much what I'd inferred of the prophet from the past two victims. But when I read "He had foreseen this moment. The Hag was dead and it was his time to show these mortals what true reckoning was," in my mind, the meaning I got from it had more to do with the Hag's role as it had to do with inhibiting the Prophet's Action rather than her mention simply being a condition of the aforementioned.

Seems I have some studying to do.

 

[Omicron]

Time to catch up on 6 pages worth of Mafia, welp.

edit: I'm not too high on damage and need to get my vote in quickly, so I'll [attack] gimmepie, nothing against you, but you can take it ;(
pls don't smash me

 

[Strange]

[attack] gimmiepie

Would you like to defend yourself?
If not I'm just going to attack marz bc I really don't know if I'm going to be on later :/

 

[Alex]

Would you like to defend yourself?
If not I'm just going to attack marz bc I really don't know if I'm going to be on later :/

I don't like third parties with as much power as he has, I'm surprised he hasn't been focused more.

 

[Christos]

[attack] gimmepie

this won't hurt you at all so please don't kill me

 

[Bidoof FTW]

attacking and saying "this wont hurt you" over and over will eventually hurt him

Jussayin

 

[Strange]

I don't like third parties with as much power as he has, I'm surprised he hasn't been focused more.

I was refering to my previous post(s):

Sure, I can go over it again:
Basically I attacked marz and none of the attacks matched mine, so I looked at all the roles that took more than 3 damage and then ruled out the ones that were already proven to be someone and that left the Bloodletter, Cutthroat, Shambler, and Blacksmith. 3 out of 4 of those are monsters, so if we attack/kill him it has a 75% chance of being a monster role killed, and some pretty powerful ones at that.

 

[Syndrome]

inb4 he dies

 

[Bidoof FTW]

So I'm just going to say that Naku was either the Occulist or the Vestal, because of
https://www.pokecommunity.com/posts/8939843/

This is him softing that he was one of the roles.
Also you can look at my quick conversation with him about it later on in that day for some more evidence

EDIT: I would look to see if he said anymore about exactly which one he was... but I'm tired and have other things to attend to.

I do know that he was healed at least once and that could be a clue to exactly which role he was, if he had been healed twice or more

 

[Candy]

Y'know phase change will be when I'm in class sooo...

[ATTACK] marz

Been pretty suss to me so far.

EDIT: oh right 4 pages in 1 night and around 4 deaths wow you guys have been busy

 

[esperance]

I really have no idea who to hit, so I'll just throw a random attack out there.

[attack] Nimsy

I don't think you've taken any damage so yeah.

 

[Klippy]

MARZ HAS BEEN SLAIN.

 

[Syndrome]

such a bloodbath

 

[Etherion]

[attack] gimmepie

 

[Ullion]

A lot of people hitting gp today, damn.

 

[Strange]

I have to attack someone and I'd rather it be a random attack than someone we know is going to help us. So.....
[Attack]Mana

 

[Fun Size]

A lot of people hitting gp today, damn.

Right now attacking GP is the safest method of getting an attack in cause if anyone questions them they can say "oh Gimme has a lot of HP so me attacking him won't do anything." I personally think Gimme might actually be willing to help us and considering he doesn't know much about anyone's roles other than what people tell us, even if he decides to help the evils it's not like he'll know who's who.

[Attack] faer

 

[faer]

Errrrrr bye Josh? What happened there? Maybe it was the mysterious -2 again? Orrrrrrr zombies.

I was checking through the last three hours of posts and despite some more expected death posts by Klippy, this was the most interesting I found.

I mean really, don't you have anything worthwhile to share? I scanned through your posts again, just to make sure my memory doesn't play me tricks this late at night, and there's really little you got to say except for jokes and stuff?