Pie Mafia [Endgame]

[Legendary Silke]

While I am curious of what happens when jd is voted, his role as a baker I think can only be beneficial for the real pies. He could maybe bake us some more pieces if we get hurt!

First day, and we can't abstain or self-vote. If you're thinking about everyone vote for each other or try and tie it up, it's not going to work because not everyone is going to participate. I'm sure we could try and scum read, but tbh the first day you can't read anything but the joker role. So heyo, random lynch based on very little let's go!

[#VOTE] Altaria
because protect the baker!

I'm pretty sure joke votes don't count... right? :P

[#VOTE] Altaria

 

[gimmepie]

I'm pretty sure joke votes don't count... right? :P

[#VOTE] Altaria

This looks crazy suss because you have been around well and truly long enough to know better.

 

[Bidoof FTW]

[#Vote] Abby

random anti-poetry vote

 

[TheCapsFan]

I don't think Abby is scum.

Twiggy's vote is very bad though. [VOTE]: Twiggy

 

[Seth Rollins]

This looks crazy suss because you have been around well and truly long enough to know better.

I don't get how it is scummy. Maybe Twiggy was doing this just to do it but I can't imagine this as something scum would do. It's something anyone could do.

That said, it seems like you're throwing some shade at Twiggy which I don't like.

 

[Wicked3DS]

I don't like being unable to abstain on D1

[VOTE] jdthebud

 

[Desinishon]

lol GP I'm busy with study and stuff :c I'll get around in weekends but other than that I'll be less active xc
We can vote for JD too in this game but JD is like baker and more likely with us ( real pies ) and voting for him lol I found that scummy c:
[Vote] Wiicked

 

[Seth Rollins]

Oops

I missed Nina's vote on Altaria

Still, this sounds normal PC like mafia gameplay, just vote for everybody on D1 and get a lynch

 

[Bidoof FTW]

It boggles my mind how the votes on GP didn't create suspicion using some of this logic

 

[Wicked3DS]

lol GP I'm busy with study and stuff :c I'll get around in weekends but other than that I'll be less active xc
We can vote for JD too in this game but JD is like baker and more likely with us ( real pies ) and voting for him lol I found that scummy c:
[Vote] Wiicked

Um...

[#VOTE] jdthebud *snicker*

Pay attention. I'm not the only one. Seems like an awfully convenient pick for you.

[UNVOTE] jdthebud

[VOTE] Lelouch

 

[Aquacorde]

johnny told me once to always follow his lead in mafia because he is good at it so

[#VOTE] Twiggy

(lol really i just dont have any better reads so.... hm)

 

[Mr Cat Dog]

My vote stays on Twiggy, though. If he flips as mafia, Seth will be a great target for next phase.

Here's my question: do mafia members normally try and openly defend their 'brethren' (for lack of a better word)? If I was a mafia member, I'd try to distance myself from the member being bandwagoned so as to deflect attention upon being lynched. Granted I'm still a bit new at this, so might have my logic a bit mixed up!

 

[Wicked3DS]

Here's my question: do mafia members normally try and openly defend their 'brethren' (for lack of a better word)? If I was a mafia member, I'd try to distance myself from the member being bandwagoned so as to deflect attention upon being lynched. Granted I'm still a bit new at this, so might have my logic a bit mixed up!

Nah you're not totally wrong, usually as a mafia you want to mix your reads so it's not painfully obvious either way. It's also good to have each mafia read differently so people don't catch on to two players being aligned the same.

 

[NightKrow]

[#VOTE] Twiggy

We called out Lucario for similar behaviour, and only let him off the hook because he's new. Twiggy isn't new so he should know what he's doing. So basically, I agree with Johnny.

also I second what Aquacorde said c:

 

[Seth Rollins]

gimmepie is obviously GIMME PIE cuz if u can see clearly, both names start with g and end with e #confirmed #exposed

[#VOTE] gimmepie

baka

Johnny does this sound like a serious vote to you.

Let me explain

I did this to get reactions but I got none, and I was disappointed. Pretty sure that's what Doof meant too

I don't get Johnny's logic he seems to think I'm a newbie mafia player smh Johnny I thought you knew me better

 

[jdthebud]

Current Vote Count:

Twiggy - 5 (Johnny, TheCapsFan, Aquacorde, Bardothren, Nightkrow)
jdthebud - 1 (Altaria)
Wiicked - 1 (Lelouch)
Lelouch - 1 (Wiicked)
Abby - 1 (Bidoof FTW)

Voteless: gimmepie, Salzorrah, Charlie Brown, Lucario, Seth Rollins, Abby, Mr Cat Dog

There are approximately 35 hours remaining in the phase.

Current Day 1 Vote Count

 

[Salzorrah]

Yeah, I'm just gonna random vote, and not join that large bandwagon tyvm

[#VOTE] Lelouch

#Winner

 

[Seth Rollins]

I FOUND MY SUSPECT just give me a minute

Yeah, I'm just gonna random vote, and not join that large bandwagon tyvm

[#VOTE] Lelouch

#Winner

>says that she dislikes bandwagons
>attempts to create one

Another point: this screams scum!Gunner all around.

scum!Gunner pretends to hate bandwagons and all just to look good in the eyes of other people. Basically, he says "I'm not joining his bandwagon yeah" to look as towny as possible.

Sorry this didn't work man @Gunner

[#UNVOTE] gimmepie
[#VOTE] Salzorrah

 

[Aquacorde]

is this a common gunner behaviour? sorry i havent been in mafia in a long time lol

 

[Seth Rollins]

It's that town!Gunner doesn't really care and would do pretty much anything

Last time I played with scum!Gunner, he avoided the whole bandwagon and pretended to hate it and such