The Darkest Dungeon

[machomuu]

You do realize that everyone who voted for GP yesterday took 2 points of damage.

At least from what I see. I'll be sure to check whether it's true. I could've done it during the night phase but eh things to do

I don't think that's the case. I looked into a lot of the damage that was dealt yesterday and what it revealed didn't necessarily have to do with damage from attacking Gimmepie for one reason or another.

Though we don't know everyone's attacks, most of the others' damage that I made note of could be traced back to somewhere in the thread, save for you.

 

[Who's Kiyo?]

I mean, the Hound Master took fifteen psyducking damage, so it makes sense that he was the main focus of the narrative, lol

Also this.

Either it's ridiculous coincidence or someone yesterday seemed like a huge threat to the groups of scum.​

 

[Omicron]

I wonder what the Brawler taking 0 damage means.

Among the possibilities that I can think of is 1) an armor stat or 2) a detective-esque role can identify who they target by the 0 marker.

I find it intriguing.

 

[Foxrally]

yeah let's not attack the big ass giant this time around

 

[Omicron]

Fox is back. Shenanigans?

 

[Ullion]

It did mention the Hound Master was following a target. And ingame, iirc, the Hound Master does have a target that involves marking an opponent (as does the Arbalest).

So maybe the Hound Master found/targeted the Brawler?

 

[Syndrome]

guys I have an idea

lets attack the big ass giant this time around

 

[Candy]

I have the same question for the Vestal.

This happened with a few roles. The Occulist and Vestal also took damage without being directly mentioned. It's likely that Klippy just isn't mentioning everything and simply deals with the major actions of the night. I mean, the Hound Master took fifteen fucking damage, so it makes sense that he was the main focus of the narrative, lol

I'm only asking this 'cause the Crusader was the one who took unexplained damaged on the first night. And last night he took an additional 3, again, with no explanation whatsoever.

Though we don't know everyone's attacks, most of the others' damage that I made note of could be traced back to somewhere in the thread, save for you.

Wait really?

*checks her list*

...oh yeah...

What's up with that? Like, I would explain if I know, but I honestly don't know. o_o

 

[Omicron]

But it says the Necromancer consumed Foxrally's remains. I don't know how that would bring him back to life, lol.

 

[Sopheria]

Looking back on things, I think going after gimmepie was a little hasty. What I find curious though, is why wasn't he targeted by any night actions? Seems like if he were a danger to the baddies, he'd be a prime target at night. I'm not trying to insinuate anything though, it's possible that I'm just missing something...

Anyways, from what I can gather, the damage shown at the end of each phase isn't cumulative. It looks like it's just the damage from that day. I'm still not sure what the -0 damage is about though. Maybe the Brawler was attacked and healed somehow? Or maybe some damage was negated?

For now though, I think the necromancer needs to be taken out sooner than later. The bloodletter seems like bad news bears too.

 

[Who's Kiyo?]

Let's not. We'll owe him a favor after he crushes the Necromancer. I think leaving him alone in the votes would be sufficient payment for his services as a villain-squasher. And if he turns on us, we turn on him. Bam.

I never knew you could pay someone in not stabbing them.

All this change of heart towards gimmie smells fishy but he is the one with the giant goddamn sword so

I'm quiet.​

 

[Alex]

Is it true all who attacked Gimmiepie yesterday took recoil damage?



[Attack] Arsonist

Most of your posts don't make sense to me. Your logic worries me and I think you're a liability.

 

[Klippy]

​

Arsonist has been slain.​

Also a note: Made an error in my post. The post has been updated to reflect damage I didn't add in. Sorry everyone!

 

[machomuu]

Is it true all who attacked Gimmiepie yesterday took recoil damage?

Unless that number is somehow variable and has a chance of not happening for certain individuals (which would be quite the stretch for innumerable reasons), no.

Ullion attacked on the previous page and saw no damage that following night, for some quick reference proof.

 

[jdthebud]

The fact that Arsonist is dead makes me wonder how much health he started with, as he took 14 damage in D1. And we know marz isn't a villager

 

[Abby]

Well, nobody's said anything about this, but I think that some of the villagers turned into these other roles due to the thing where they had to pm klippy numbers. Also, the quickness of arsonist's death makes me fell that we just killed an innocent villager.

 

[Etherion]

"This time...there would be no mistakes."

This led me to think that maybe the Hound Keeper was roleblocked? Or something.

 

[machomuu]

Well, nobody's said anything about this, but I think that some of the villagers turned into these other roles due to the thing where they had to pm klippy numbers. Also, the quickness of arsonist's death makes me fell that we just killed an innocent villager.

I'm gonna have to say that, as much as that makes sense from a numbers perspective, that's pretty unlikely.

To support this, I point to Spectrum. Spectrum got attacked twice yesterday for a grand total of 12 damage, once by Arsonist, and once by (a rather tipsy) Zeffy. Now, you could make the argument that Zeffy did 10 damage (which, judging from the spread, is pretty unlikely in itself) and that Arsonist did 2, or Spectrum took mysteriously took damage from something else in the same way that Candy did, but consider what Arsonist said just before his attack:

We can be death bros then!

Though I personally call the sanity of Arsonist's character into question, and he was pretty heated at the time, this does suggest that he can do at least enough damage that Spectrum wouldn't just yawn it off. Despite Zeffy having been drunk/tipsy/buzzed yesterday, he attacked specifically for the sake of spreading damage, not with the intent to kill. Were they coordinating? Less than likely; it seems more as if Zeffy just attacked him because someone else on the same page did and that was an opportunity to spread.

Unlikely isn't impossible, of course, and this is all speculation based on inference (though I do feel that the amount of damage Spec took is pretty telling). But if anyone'd know if he was a Villager or not...it'd probably be Zeffy.

 

[Zeffy]

I attacked Spectrum because they were the last poster before me. I was tipsy so I haven't been exactly paying attention to who was attacking who, and I don't exactly deal a lot of damage--especially not 10! As much as I'd like to tell you what the hell user Arsonist was thinking, I don't know anything about him except for the fact that he's become really defensive after being called out by someone.

EDIT: This is just based on speculation but in the Day post, both the Swine Prince and the Crusader took 3 damage. During night 0, the Bloodletter attacked both of them. It could be possible that a) the Bloodletter attacked both of them again (it was the same amount of damage) or b) the Bloodletter's attacks cause bleeding.

 

[Abby]

Sigh, This is annoying not knowing if we killed an innocent or not,