Faeries & Legends [Night Four - Banquet]

Nimsy said:
We usually go by em rules.
And if mafia visits the granny, they all die.

The only reason they all didn't die was because of the Valkyrie.
Click to expand...

On EM the mafia kills by majority vote. Any mafia that didn't vote the target don't visit the target.


I'm still trying to catch up on the thread. This is gonna be my whole day, isn't it?
 
Salzorrah said:
You know, I could have stayed quiet, but I did it anyway, like ALL OF MY OTHER ****IN REVEALS IN OTHER GAMES BECAUSE I ****IN ACTUALLY WANT TOWN TO WIN. SERIOUSLY, IF YOU DON'T WANT MY HELP THEN TELL ME. Geez, if mafia had not N0'd me, I'd consider joining them >.>
Click to expand...

But you're a granny - and you've been revealed. So going from this point in the game - how do you plan to help us? :/ While voting for you straight away isn't the best option, it certainly does strike me as a better option than random lynching (where we have a reasonable chance of lynching someone who has an actually useful ability). I won't vote for you, yet - but if things continue this way I will since I really doubt we'll get a solid scum read on this day phase.
 
I'm kind of sympathetic to third parties. Alone against the world.... if they're not harmful to the town I'd say they should be kept alive.

I disagree with the notion of lynching a third party just because they're not one of us, since they can be just as useful, and even moreso than some townies.
 
Johnny raises some good points. But I'm not very eager to trust anyone myself, considering that it is almost (if not completely) certain that someone posting is trying to get their malicious way.

And Gunner, I think for people you accused to be voting for you, isn't all that illogical.
 
Maybe, but thats my personal notes on that matter, no one should probably follow up on that really, unless you got some substantial evidence of course.

#thirdpartylivesmatter
 
The only one a granny role would be detrimental to is the mafia, since they have to outnumber to win.
I say we keep her alive and just make sure we don't visit her.

Also, in that strain of thought, those voting for her look p scummy.
 
No reason to vote gunner as long as no one visits her she'll just be another town vote. I don't have much to add but going for gunner seems like a scummy move as day actions are the most reliable way to take out the Granny especially with a Valkyrie as well. Let's just leave Baba Yaga alone and hope she doesn't decide to eat our children.
 
Well, there really is no reason to lynch her. She's only a threat to bad guys at this point so pressing for her death is very suspicious. A lot of people are probably worried about becoming one of Moses' / Lil Bo-Peep's minions too so I suspect that there won't be a lot of voting until near the end of the phase. Even then, I expect it to be random voting.
 
I won't attack Gunner neither will I defend Gunner.

It just seems way too convenient to have an obvious lynch choice day one that I feel like we are overlooking something.

Although... I am craving a little roasted old lady for dinner. :3
 
Johnny said:
Voting for third party on day one is scummy? I rate that logic 5/7

With so many people lowkey defending Gunner I'm starting to think she's mafia; it wouldn't surprise me tbh, if someone were to pull off something like that, it'd be Gunner.
Click to expand...

If Gunner is mafia (which I highly doubt) then it's safe to assume some of the people defending her and not voting her are also sided with her.

Syndrome said:
Well, there really is no reason to lynch her. She's only a threat to bad guys at this point so pressing for her death is very suspicious. A lot of people are probably worried about becoming one of Moses' / Lil Bo-Peep's minions too so I suspect that there won't be a lot of voting until near the end of the phase. Even then, I expect it to be random voting.
Click to expand...

Now that everyone knows who she is, she can't be a threat to anyone. I don't really know what you thought when you said "she's only a threat to the bad guys."

Johnny said:
She's not a threat to the bad guys, that is fact. Because they know who she is and won't visit her (in case she's telling the truth)

On the other hand, she could be lying, she could have a different win condition, she could side with mafia for all we know. So why keep a role like that and random vote instead? When chances are that we're gonna hit an innocent.

As I see it, you're asking to switch from a win/win situation to something that could screw us.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I'd rather hit a 100% 3rd Party/maf VS. Randomly voting. Gunner could easily be lying and be mafia, so there's still no reason not to lynch her.

##Burn Gunner
 
Johnny said:
How?

You shouldn't speak in such a cryptic manner. It's your ass that is on the line.
Click to expand...

Johnny Baba Yaga has the ability to visit someone every night, helping or hindering them, to answer your question.

I don't think that people voting for Gunner are suspicious at all, they're just taking a different route. A perfectly valid one at that, it's not like lynching a townie, if anything they're less suspicious. It's not the ideal route, but it's certainly better than a random lynch.

I agree with Ullion, I'd rather not lynch Gunner, but it looks like we have no solid alternatives, so that's what I'm leaning toward.
 
Until the Firebird dies Baba Yaga can't really kill anybody and there aren't any win conditions set, so they're probably just meant to be there to survive. It's better to keep gunner alive because she may empower a role, which is dominantly town filled, and helping us out in the long run.
 
Is it me or ewery's lines always somewhat contradicts each other...*shrugs*

Like pecillia stated as long as Firebird is alive, gunner is good if she stays town. If gunner says she will be loyal then she will.
#highlightes dawnfia
Gunner didn't sided with us.....
O: HOLY MUK I got killed in that game 3 times...... That emblem should have my name...

I know lynching gunner is better than any random lynch but I ain't lynching her for time being....
 
That was naku's other game where gunner was Hannah windego something and she has to survive till end, she got revealed and she choose to help town and she really did. That's from other game though xD.
I got killed in that game like 3 times .....I dunno
So you liked story johnny! C:
 
Johnny, you are trying so hard to pin Gunner. xD
You better be careful, if Gunner isn't a maf you get burned instead.
If I were you I'd stay silent at this stage and observe the sus until something proves the suspected person to be a real scum.
 
Sun said:
Johnny, you are trying so hard to pin Gunner. xD
You better be careful, if Gunner isn't a maf you get burned instead.
If I were you I'd stay silent at this stage and observe the sus until something proves the suspected person to be a real scum.
Click to expand...

Not really.
There's like a say... 5% chance she's maf with the other 95% being she's a third party (numbers pulled out of my ass to illustrate the point). Either way we're lynching someone who isn't townsided.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top